WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:07.309
Winton: And so I'm continuing on from Steven's talk this morning about

2
00:00:07.420 --> 00:00:15.900
Winton: work or camantha and I just want to reinf sort of bad

3
00:00:18.020 --> 00:00:20.929
Winton: re-emphasize how important this

4
00:00:21.930 --> 00:00:29.289
Winton: reinterpretation of the path is, because work is such an important part of

5
00:00:29.540 --> 00:00:34.189
Winton: everybody's lives. I mean, we spend

6
00:00:34.620 --> 00:00:46.720
Winton: perhaps the most time as awake energetic individuals and the working day. and so is very much part of our

7
00:00:47.460 --> 00:00:52.090
Winton: spiritual development and our spiritual practice.

8
00:00:53.350 --> 00:01:00.110
Winton: And we all know about labour. We spoke about yesterday

9
00:01:01.370 --> 00:01:10.230
Winton: what the Bible calls earning our daily bread by the sweat of our brow. and then goes on to say.

10
00:01:10.890 --> 00:01:14.280
but one lives not by bread alone.

11
00:01:14.790 --> 00:01:20.920
Winton: And so let's explore that proposition.

12
00:01:21.930 --> 00:01:27.190
Winton: And so it's also

13
00:01:27.240 --> 00:01:30.630
Winton: useful that to Stephen in the handout

14
00:01:30.710 --> 00:01:34.120
Winton: has referred to Gotamas

15
00:01:34.850 --> 00:01:42.409
Winton: reference to the internal self-creating activity of work.

16
00:01:43.490 --> 00:01:45.030
Winton: So

17
00:01:47.330 --> 00:01:51.490
Winton: He also, of course, cites Hannah Arendt

18
00:01:51.540 --> 00:01:58.799
Winton: and her concept of human of us humans as Homo Faber.

19
00:01:59.400 --> 00:02:03.090
Winton: the creatures that create things.

20
00:02:03.400 --> 00:02:13.439
Winton: and I'm pretty sure she's she's probably onto a theme that was first brought up

21
00:02:14.480 --> 00:02:16.690
Winton: by Kalmarx

22
00:02:16.700 --> 00:02:21.870
Winton: in his 1844 manuscripts.

23
00:02:22.430 --> 00:02:29.249
Winton: Now in Karl Marx was a young man just setting out to

24
00:02:29.400 --> 00:02:38.769
Winton: overthrow all known authorities in the world, and he got into this issue of Homo Faber.

25
00:02:39.130 --> 00:02:45.700
Winton: and he referred to. He referred to it in another expression of his called species being

26
00:02:45.870 --> 00:02:47.979
Winton: that work meaning.

27
00:02:48.460 --> 00:02:50.979
the ability to create

28
00:02:51.320 --> 00:02:59.170
Winton: ability to create with tools mainly that was specific to human beings

29
00:02:59.450 --> 00:03:02.920
as opposed to the rest of the animal kingdom.

30
00:03:03.850 --> 00:03:12.360
Winton: And it's interesting that he explored this idea as he was scribbling away on a first draft of something.

31
00:03:12.480 --> 00:03:15.720
Winton: and then he

32
00:03:15.790 --> 00:03:22.270
Winton: He got caught up in other events going on in Europe. and he consigned this

33
00:03:22.580 --> 00:03:25.730
Winton: these manuscripts to the attic.

34
00:03:26.000 --> 00:03:31.330
Winton: as he put it, to the gnawing criticism of the rats

35
00:03:31.800 --> 00:03:33.270
but, as it turned out.

36
00:03:33.710 --> 00:03:48.460
Winton: the rats had few criticisms, and so, over a century later the 1844 manuscripts saw the light of day, and their publication was something of a sensation.

37
00:03:48.980 --> 00:03:50.990
Winton: And

38
00:03:51.530 --> 00:03:55.089
Winton: I hope I can mention the name of Karl Marx without

39
00:03:55.440 --> 00:04:05.359
Winton: frightening the horses, because we we were able to talk about. Make your belly and remain calm the day before yesterday.

40
00:04:05.400 --> 00:04:07.050
Winton: and,

41
00:04:07.170 --> 00:04:18.990
Winton: The the reason I am fairly familiar with this stuff. Is that UN quite unbeknown to me? There was a a massive

42
00:04:20.070 --> 00:04:24.890
Winton: Reclaiming and reissuing of Marx's thought.

43
00:04:25.030 --> 00:04:37.419
Winton: Marx isthought in the 19 seventies, when I just happened to turn up at the London School of Economics as a graduate student and found one of my teachers was a

44
00:04:37.450 --> 00:04:40.789
Winton: leader in this movement called Ralph Miliband

45
00:04:41.090 --> 00:04:52.189
Winton: and the kind of Marxism that was being revived had absolutely nothing to do with what was going on in the Soviet bloc.

46
00:04:52.730 --> 00:05:03.129
Winton: It was pretty clear that when Marx was invoked by Soviet authorities it was a case of misleading advertising.

47
00:05:03.300 --> 00:05:09.780
Winton: because There was really nothing in Marx's writing that could

48
00:05:10.050 --> 00:05:19.549
Winton: that could beautify or excuse what was happening in the Soviet bloc and further east.

49
00:05:20.170 --> 00:05:36.900
Winton: So so we we all learnt about. We all read the 1844 manuscripts and other pieces of Marx's writing, and of course the great classic capital in 3 volumes, and

50
00:05:37.260 --> 00:05:47.870
Winton: Ralph Miliband used to refer to him as the old boy, and there was quite a cult around the old boy.

51
00:05:48.070 --> 00:05:59.210
Winton: The old boy did a lot of his research in the reading room for the British Museum in Central London, and there was quite a lot of competition

52
00:05:59.220 --> 00:06:07.889
Winton: to go there and sit in Seat E. 5, which we all knew the old boy had sat in and then we.

53
00:06:08.080 --> 00:06:11.969
Winton: And then, of course, we went and did homage to him in

54
00:06:12.080 --> 00:06:17.889
Winton: Highgate Cemetery, in in Northern London. But the

55
00:06:18.640 --> 00:06:26.610
Winton: the idea that in in his early Marx was that  Human beings are

56
00:06:26.670 --> 00:06:30.040
Winton: essentially creative, and

57
00:06:30.200 --> 00:06:40.620
Winton: what happens when they sell their labor to an employer was that they alienate their creativity.

58
00:06:40.990 --> 00:06:45.390
Winton: their work ceases to be theirs.

59
00:06:45.540 --> 00:06:59.379
Winton: it ceases to be an expression of them. And therefore this is a theory of alienation. So basically, what workers did

60
00:06:59.720 --> 00:07:03.120
Winton: in factories and so forth, was

61
00:07:03.410 --> 00:07:06.050
a form of alienation, a form

62
00:07:07.340 --> 00:07:15.829
Winton: of reduction of one's human capacities and and a

63
00:07:16.080 --> 00:07:21.900
Winton: and a shrinking of the human condition. So

64
00:07:24.330 --> 00:07:33.350
Winton: I'll certainly be coming back to this in relation to the work of of Martin Hegelund.

65
00:07:33.360 --> 00:07:40.579
Winton: however, mentioned already in terms of secular faith. He was the secular faith author.

66
00:07:41.240 --> 00:07:45.810
Winton: But I just want to talk about how

67
00:07:46.350 --> 00:07:54.759
Winton: how this alienation became intensified as capitalism became more and more mechanized

68
00:07:55.000 --> 00:08:03.070
Winton: and so we move swiftly forward to the late nineteenth century. to an American

69
00:08:03.240 --> 00:08:04.940
Winton: engineer

70
00:08:05.090 --> 00:08:09.299
Winton: called Frederick Frederick Winslow Taylor.

71
00:08:09.550 --> 00:08:12.889
Winton: who wrote a book called Scientific Management.

72
00:08:13.080 --> 00:08:15.440
Winton: Now Taylor

73
00:08:15.660 --> 00:08:28.029
Winton: was the inventor of the assembly line, and the acme of his of his discovery was Henry Ford's assembly line

74
00:08:28.090 --> 00:08:35.310
Winton: assembling T model forwards, and Taylor's idea was that you could make

75
00:08:35.470 --> 00:08:38.830
Winton: and make workers much more productive

76
00:08:38.960 --> 00:08:41.970
Winton: if you if you broke the

77
00:08:42.039 --> 00:08:43.830
Winton: production process up

78
00:08:43.950 --> 00:08:48.739
Winton: into tiny little moments. Tiny little pieces.

79
00:08:48.900 --> 00:09:06.890
Winton: and each worker then took charge of one of these tiny little pieces like bolting on the rear bumper bar of a T model forward or securing the steering wheel to the steering column. So basically, workers were being

80
00:09:07.410 --> 00:09:08.650
condemned

81
00:09:08.680 --> 00:09:09.750
Winton: to

82
00:09:09.920 --> 00:09:15.619
Winton: this kind of endlessly monotonous, tiny moments of work

83
00:09:15.870 --> 00:09:18.150
Winton: bolting on the bumper bar.

84
00:09:18.260 --> 00:09:23.279
Winton: bolting on the steering wheel. And that was so. Every

85
00:09:23.560 --> 00:09:31.120
Winton: ounce of creativity and charm in the work was squeezed out of it and and

86
00:09:31.340 --> 00:09:34.749
Winton: This system was called

87
00:09:35.070 --> 00:09:49.320
Winton: Averism, and it led to another ism called Forwardism, because Ford was the classic example of how it worked, and it became a socioeconomic system in that

88
00:09:49.570 --> 00:09:53.610
Winton: these workers who were treated like trained monkeys.

89
00:09:53.980 --> 00:09:57.789
Winton: At least had a wage. You can't above

90
00:09:57.940 --> 00:10:23.790
Winton: other workers, so that in time they could, if they were abstinious and responsible with their money they could actually buy a T model forward, and and thus they could become what became known as the literature. As instrumental workers. They, they, their working days, were spent in alienated labour.

91
00:10:24.350 --> 00:10:33.090
Winton: totally charmless, and yet they apparently were satisfied with the fact that they could

92
00:10:33.120 --> 00:10:41.300
Winton: acquire a certain amount of personal wealth like a motor car, and maybe even in time.

93
00:10:41.400 --> 00:10:42.819
Winton: a house to live in.

94
00:10:43.560 --> 00:10:48.419
Winton: So so in this way Taylorism became forwardism.

95
00:10:48.680 --> 00:10:58.520
Winton: The wages that the slightly better paid workers in the car factory made created a demand

96
00:10:58.740 --> 00:11:00.749
Winton: for the product.

97
00:11:00.950 --> 00:11:09.490
Winton: There was a bit of money in circulation, so Henry Ford could sell his cars and so

98
00:11:11.240 --> 00:11:21.819
Winton: what is important here, I think, is the way, what is the motive behind this? And it has a lot to do with the central

99
00:11:21.830 --> 00:11:23.680
Winton: problem. Let Heg Loan

100
00:11:23.760 --> 00:11:27.129
Winton: is raising, and which is

101
00:11:27.150 --> 00:11:36.660
Winton: that is time we are mortal creatures. We measure out our lives in time. So

102
00:11:37.050 --> 00:11:48.349
Winton: what was also clear about about Taylorism was that the the line kept on the assembly line kept on being speeded up.

103
00:11:48.830 --> 00:12:04.429
Winton: so that so that the work become much more and more intense, and more and more things could be produced for less and less outlay in terms of workers, wages.

104
00:12:06.540 --> 00:12:08.889
Winton: and Marx

105
00:12:09.470 --> 00:12:13.249
Winton: when he when he when he himself

106
00:12:13.800 --> 00:12:18.229
Winton: stopped focusing on the issue of alienation

107
00:12:18.330 --> 00:12:37.859
Winton: and moved on to that is often that's often called the humanist Marx. He then became the political economy Marx and he was. He became less interested in that in the alienation issue. He didn't leave it behind. But he began to explain how

108
00:12:38.000 --> 00:12:44.230
Winton: this business of kind of of of conceptually

109
00:12:44.890 --> 00:12:48.330
Winton: covering up the time a worker spent

110
00:12:49.260 --> 00:12:52.910
Winton: in terms of what part of it was necessary

111
00:12:53.560 --> 00:12:56.659
Winton: for the worker to create value

112
00:12:56.750 --> 00:12:59.760
Winton: that would replace.

113
00:13:00.110 --> 00:13:02.000
Winton: hurdle his wages.

114
00:13:02.140 --> 00:13:16.909
Winton: and any other on costs of employing him or her, and what part of the working day and the value created during that part of the working day went straight into the pocket of the capitalist

115
00:13:17.690 --> 00:13:27.050
Winton: whom Marx tended to call money bags, and so the more the more

116
00:13:27.910 --> 00:13:31.249
Winton: money bags could she could squeeze

117
00:13:31.840 --> 00:13:42.169
Winton: the amount of necessary labour, time necessary to reproduce the worker and her or his family, etc. And

118
00:13:42.450 --> 00:13:48.209
Winton: and by the same token increase the amount of surplus time

119
00:13:48.550 --> 00:13:51.820
Winton: that the worker is still on the job.

120
00:13:51.980 --> 00:13:55.820
That meant higher profit rate, and that's what it.

121
00:13:56.240 --> 00:14:01.760
Winton: What moneybags was after, of course, was increasing the rate of profit.

122
00:14:02.740 --> 00:14:04.240
Winton: And so

123
00:14:04.390 --> 00:14:06.510
Winton: this, this

124
00:14:06.830 --> 00:14:16.340
Winton: surplus time and those values that it created there was created during that time was called surplus value.

125
00:14:16.510 --> 00:14:25.100
Winton: This is Marxian economics, 101. So what does this mean in terms of

126
00:14:25.510 --> 00:14:29.780
Winton: what's what's happening today, for instance.

127
00:14:29.860 --> 00:14:39.069
Winton: now now nowadays, with with neoliberalism? Of course, the picture has become slightly more complicated because

128
00:14:39.110 --> 00:14:41.309
Winton: it's no longer

129
00:14:41.400 --> 00:14:45.210
Winton: Moneybags, who was an industrial capitalist.

130
00:14:45.300 --> 00:14:55.969
Winton: interested in making, in having things made and selling them on the market to whoever had could afford to buy them. He was not making them

131
00:14:56.040 --> 00:15:02.039
Winton: to satisfy human needs. He was selling them to make money.

132
00:15:02.390 --> 00:15:04.969
Winton: So this is the dissociation

133
00:15:05.210 --> 00:15:10.000
Winton:  From the production system, on the one hand.

134
00:15:10.040 --> 00:15:15.480
Winton: from human needs on the other, which is basic to capitalism.

135
00:15:16.290 --> 00:15:20.160
Winton: And this this step is often

136
00:15:20.680 --> 00:15:26.350
Winton: misunderstood that that we think that what is being produced

137
00:15:26.460 --> 00:15:28.099
Winton: and is turning up

138
00:15:28.200 --> 00:15:33.260
Winton: in our lives as cars and air conditioners and refrigerators. Well.

139
00:15:33.960 --> 00:15:40.590
Winton: it's not. It's being. It's but they are all being produced for it to be sold, not to be used

140
00:15:41.020 --> 00:15:51.119
Winton: if they get used. Well, that's another story. But Moneybags isn't interested in whether they're used or not. Now, with sat neoliberalism.

141
00:15:52.140 --> 00:15:54.800
industrial capitalists like

142
00:15:55.070 --> 00:15:56.870
Winton: Money bags

143
00:15:57.170 --> 00:16:00.510
Winton: was. It were eclipsed

144
00:16:00.620 --> 00:16:03.910
Winton: by finance, capital banking.

145
00:16:06.050 --> 00:16:15.810
Winton: all sorts of institutional employers and people who were who were just investors looking for to buy and sell

146
00:16:16.090 --> 00:16:21.170
Winton: stock at the highest profit. So when

147
00:16:21.370 --> 00:16:27.930
Winton:  to to sort of. Make a long story as short as possible. When finance, capital

148
00:16:28.270 --> 00:16:31.230
Winton: eclipsed industrial capital.

149
00:16:31.350 --> 00:16:44.669
Winton: It imposed this new system called neoliberalism, and the point of that well, there are a number of points of it. One was globalization, which was a political project, often

150
00:16:44.750 --> 00:16:47.520
Winton: sold as a natural

151
00:16:47.540 --> 00:16:54.399
Winton: wonder, but it was very much a political project, so that capital could move around the world

152
00:16:55.050 --> 00:16:58.739
Winton: easily if there was a better profit to be

153
00:16:58.910 --> 00:17:09.080
Winton: to, you know, to be to be made in Turkey instead of instead of Britain. Then all the money went to Turkey. There was to be no barriers

154
00:17:09.180 --> 00:17:13.299
Winton: to where capital could go to seek

155
00:17:13.310 --> 00:17:19.859
Winton: the Heist return. So this in turn created

156
00:17:20.740 --> 00:17:22.829
Winton: huge, knew

157
00:17:24.450 --> 00:17:28.660
Winton: activities in finance in the finance world.

158
00:17:29.660 --> 00:17:32.709
Winton: and which were absolutely unproductive.

159
00:17:33.380 --> 00:17:43.079
Winton: No food or cars or clothes come out of Wall Street or out of the capital C, city of London.

160
00:17:43.440 --> 00:17:46.839
or out of the European Common Central Bank.

161
00:17:46.850 --> 00:17:50.790
Winton: the relationship of finance.

162
00:17:50.960 --> 00:17:56.820
Winton: But the financial system to the real economy is a purely extractive one.

163
00:17:57.230 --> 00:18:24.189
Winton: It's absolutely unproductive, as are the other creatures of neoliberalism like managers. Suddenly there all these managers appear. They're an invasive species in university life, and many other places where suddenly the life of teachers and academics and lots of other professions were taken up.

164
00:18:24.390 --> 00:18:28.590
Winton: Filling out forms for managers, you know,

165
00:18:28.640 --> 00:18:40.309
Winton: for things that were often called orders, or something like that. But, as you're probably aware, many teachers complain bitterly that so much of their time is spent

166
00:18:40.510 --> 00:18:43.729
Winton: filling in forms, not teaching, not

167
00:18:43.930 --> 00:18:48.279
Winton: reading, books about how to improve the syllabus, but in

168
00:18:48.690 --> 00:18:54.120
Winton: in giving an account of themselves to these creatures called managers

169
00:18:54.410 --> 00:18:56.000
Winton: and

170
00:18:56.230 --> 00:19:01.500
Winton: So when we get back to this issue of human need.

171
00:19:01.730 --> 00:19:04.939
Winton: we see that there's a huge number of people

172
00:19:04.970 --> 00:19:12.930
Winton: who are taking out lots and lots of money out of the economy and and putting nothing back in return.

173
00:19:12.980 --> 00:19:21.479
Winton: They're basically parasitical. So and at the same time, of course, working hours are increasing.

174
00:19:22.320 --> 00:19:26.669
Winton: There's no way in which technology, which is

175
00:19:26.880 --> 00:19:33.899
Winton: actually reducing the amount of necessary labour time and

176
00:19:34.010 --> 00:19:51.949
Winton: reducing the socially necessary time it takes to feed and clothe and house people. While that's going on. We've got, you know, terrific technology to do that. We're all working longer and longer, and those who are working who are selling their labour.

177
00:19:52.120 --> 00:20:06.039
Winton: living on salaries and wages. Their their standard, their wealth, income, and life chances are reducing at as against those who are milking the system

178
00:20:06.140 --> 00:20:12.060
Winton: through the through the financial system. So what

179
00:20:13.750 --> 00:20:20.729
Winton:  Martin Hegelund is saying. Well, let's get back to

180
00:20:21.080 --> 00:20:24.329
Winton: Marx's basic propositions

181
00:20:24.410 --> 00:20:28.620
Winton: and saying, Let's imagine an economy now

182
00:20:28.710 --> 00:20:30.130
Winton: which

183
00:20:30.150 --> 00:20:31.929
Winton: which

184
00:20:33.110 --> 00:20:45.050
Winton: enjoys the productivity improvements that have been created under industrial capitalism. and then think about what we, what we really need.

185
00:20:45.430 --> 00:20:56.080
Winton: You know, how many new shirts do we need, and how many new cars and all the rest of it, and and think about how how much

186
00:20:56.100 --> 00:20:58.840
Winton: socially necessary time

187
00:20:58.890 --> 00:21:04.940
Winton: would be spent producing those things. Assuming we're all going to have to to work

188
00:21:05.390 --> 00:21:07.629
Winton: to some extent to

189
00:21:07.640 --> 00:21:11.590
Winton: to support ourselves, to support our

190
00:21:12.080 --> 00:21:19.329
Winton: our dependence, and it put the many people in society who are not in a position

191
00:21:19.380 --> 00:21:22.109
Winton: to support themselves.

192
00:21:22.260 --> 00:21:23.440
Winton: So

193
00:21:23.570 --> 00:21:32.070
Winton: we put all the human conditions of society there, and see how how much necessary, socially necessary

194
00:21:32.090 --> 00:21:36.059
Winton: time it would take to produce what's necessary for them.

195
00:21:36.610 --> 00:21:42.240
Winton: And then, if we, if we abolish this present system.

196
00:21:42.660 --> 00:21:50.640
Winton: I was just thinking hypothetically, we would all have an awful lot of free time.

197
00:21:51.010 --> 00:21:57.449
Winton: and that is the time we can spend meditating, reading, getting educated.

198
00:21:57.920 --> 00:22:08.949
Winton: we would be. We would be enjoying what he calls ultimately spiritual freedom. no longer engaged in

199
00:22:08.980 --> 00:22:13.510
Winton: alienated work, but in a position to

200
00:22:13.870 --> 00:22:21.350
Winton: achieve, to pursue our human goals. Interestingly, he doesn't seem to realize this, but

201
00:22:21.490 --> 00:22:25.429
Winton: John Maynard came. He just came up with the same idea.

202
00:22:26.510 --> 00:22:27.959
Winton: After the Second World War.

203
00:22:27.970 --> 00:22:28.990
he said.

204
00:22:29.210 --> 00:22:35.950
Winton: we have mastered the arts of production. Now we should dedicate ourselves

205
00:22:36.010 --> 00:22:38.560
Winton: to the arts of life.

206
00:22:39.260 --> 00:22:47.810
Winton: Think I've quoted that earlier. And this is he's getting at basically basically the same idea. So

207
00:22:48.440 --> 00:22:53.240
Winton:  perhaps I'll just make I made some notes.

208
00:22:53.980 --> 00:23:00.550
Winton: I'll just read them selectively about where Headland ends South.

209
00:23:00.990 --> 00:23:11.639
Winton: He says, the first principle of his new system, which he calls democratic Socialism, and I should say that what he means by that is that

210
00:23:11.650 --> 00:23:13.889
Winton: the production system

211
00:23:14.180 --> 00:23:16.440
Winton: is a public affair.

212
00:23:16.590 --> 00:23:21.300
Winton: Ray's publica gets back to civic republicanism.

213
00:23:21.610 --> 00:23:29.740
Winton: so these, the production system is a public affair, and therefore it should be.

214
00:23:29.960 --> 00:23:34.700
Winton: It should be governed by the public. and

215
00:23:35.240 --> 00:23:43.470
Winton: at the, at each point of enterprise, or each factory, each place where something is being produced.

216
00:23:43.650 --> 00:23:50.910
Winton: it should be the how it is run should be the business of the people working in it.

217
00:23:51.360 --> 00:24:02.940
Winton: Industrial democracy, economic democracy. So the first principle of democratic Socialism is that we measure our wealth.

218
00:24:03.400 --> 00:24:09.209
Winton: individual and collective, in terms of socially available free time.

219
00:24:09.590 --> 00:24:13.690
Winton: So this is the number. One measure of wealth is

220
00:24:14.200 --> 00:24:18.720
Winton: is, how little time we need to spend

221
00:24:19.600 --> 00:24:24.839
Winton: reproducing the material preconditions of our lives, and

222
00:24:24.860 --> 00:24:25.970
Winton: how much

223
00:24:26.020 --> 00:24:32.589
Winton: greater is the time that we can spend in our free pursuits.

224
00:24:33.180 --> 00:24:36.800
Winton: in our free time, where we are expressing

225
00:24:37.180 --> 00:24:40.230
power. human, potential.

226
00:24:42.400 --> 00:24:56.860
Winton:  And he says that a second principle of democratic Socialism is the means of production, are collectively owned, and cannot be used for the sake of profit.

227
00:24:57.510 --> 00:25:07.799
Winton: Clearly every every enterprise, every factory, every farm. needs to have an operating surplus.

228
00:25:07.950 --> 00:25:15.280
Winton: There needs to be a reinvestment, a repair and

229
00:25:15.860 --> 00:25:18.110
Winton: and modernization of equipment.

230
00:25:18.210 --> 00:25:27.690
Winton: But that doesn't have to be profit. It can be just simply taking the operating surplus and reinvesting it straight back into

231
00:25:28.020 --> 00:25:29.510
back into the

232
00:25:29.940 --> 00:25:32.259
Winton: productive enterprise.

233
00:25:32.320 --> 00:25:45.689
Winton: And it doesn't have to go to the Cayman Islands or any other tax haven, or to buy a house on the harbour for 75 million dollars.

234
00:25:45.700 --> 00:25:56.560
Winton: It can go just straight back into into the productive enterprise or back into the pockets of the people who've actually generated the wealth. In the first place.

235
00:25:57.400 --> 00:25:59.909
Winton: and then

236
00:26:00.270 --> 00:26:02.450
Winton: the third principle is

237
00:26:02.560 --> 00:26:11.430
Winton: from each according to her ability, to each according to her needs. Leonard equated that last night on the screen.

238
00:26:11.450 --> 00:26:16.690
Winton: So that that would be the basic basic idea. and

239
00:26:16.980 --> 00:26:30.390
Winton: so at at all points where decisions were being made, they would be made in in the public realm, whatever the that realm was, but's in the enterprise be those working in the enterprise.

240
00:26:30.860 --> 00:26:44.950
Winton: If it's at a regional level, it be made by people in the region, if it's made by national at the national level in terms of economic policy, etc. It would be a question of a democratically elected

241
00:26:44.980 --> 00:26:46.050
Winton: government

242
00:26:46.300 --> 00:26:56.010
Winton: where obviously there would be quite a lot of politics going on at all levels. But that is, you know, this is who we are. We're political animals as well.

243
00:26:56.730 --> 00:26:58.290
Winton: So

244
00:26:59.570 --> 00:27:14.089
Winton:  as he says, because we are fragile, embodied beings. We need shelter, nourishment, and health and health care not only to survive, but also to maintain our spiritual commitments.

245
00:27:14.840 --> 00:27:21.540
Winton: Likewise we need tools and various forms of infrastructure to pursue our spiritual projects.

246
00:27:21.820 --> 00:27:31.670
Winton: Now, what he's proposing of course, means that there would still be jobs that are necessary to be done, but they may not be done by alienated labour.

247
00:27:31.970 --> 00:27:46.470
Winton: You know some people like curing other people, and to become doctors and nurses, and some people like thinking up new buildings architects. So they're expressing they're not, and that's not alienated labor. Then.

248
00:27:46.770 --> 00:27:50.570
They're expressing their species being.

249
00:27:51.030 --> 00:27:52.740
Winton: And so

250
00:27:52.960 --> 00:28:01.809
Winton: what jobs would be left for alienated labor they put should be shared around collecting the garbage and all that sort of thing.

251
00:28:01.830 --> 00:28:07.550
Winton: but clearly we would be in a much better positioned as

252
00:28:07.800 --> 00:28:11.469
Winton: to make sense of our lives and to pursue our

253
00:28:12.200 --> 00:28:22.639
Winton: our spiritual aspirations in such a world. And that's what Hegelons argument is. Now. He's not setting up any kind of

254
00:28:23.020 --> 00:28:28.730
Winton: Utopia, and certainly marks. And if it did anything like that, he bitterly criticised.

255
00:28:29.350 --> 00:28:34.950
Winton: The French Utopian Marxist, the French Utopian Socialists

256
00:28:35.330 --> 00:28:41.609
Winton: for doing just that. And you know, when people talk about Marxist Socialism.

257
00:28:41.720 --> 00:28:50.369
Winton: they don't know what Marx actually wrote. He he was against all those sorts of blueprints and Utopias, because

258
00:28:51.090 --> 00:28:56.550
Winton: how systems change transitions. how they work.

259
00:28:56.940 --> 00:28:58.789
Depends upon

260
00:28:59.070 --> 00:29:04.850
Winton: what people decide at the time and the kind of institutions they've inherited.

261
00:29:05.370 --> 00:29:07.100
Winton: You know, it's the beginning of

262
00:29:07.180 --> 00:29:13.689
Winton: one of his famous historical essays, the eighteenth Brew, mayor of Louis Bonaparte. He says.

263
00:29:13.730 --> 00:29:16.109
Winton: people make their own history.

264
00:29:16.120 --> 00:29:29.179
Winton: but they do not do so as they may choose, but in accordance with inherited conditions. So how this would work out, of course, would depend upon

265
00:29:29.550 --> 00:29:32.109
Winton: existing institutions existing

266
00:29:32.380 --> 00:29:39.290
Winton: are desires and obviously pre-existing resistance to what's being proposed.

267
00:29:39.420 --> 00:29:43.770
Winton: which at the moment is formidable. But

268
00:29:44.230 --> 00:29:58.999
Winton: Anyway, it's a sort of a counterfactual to the problems of work we've been exploring, and that Anna Arrent herself was also exploring in the 19 fifties. So perhaps I should leave it there.

269
00:29:59.150 --> 00:30:03.529
Winton: And People can ask questions of my comments.

270
00:30:10.810 --> 00:30:11.650
Winton: Texas.

271
00:30:20.920 --> 00:30:24.640
Winton: that's right. Yeah, I'm the runner. thanks, Rana.

272
00:30:25.250 --> 00:30:33.679
Winton: Very interesting. Thank you. Wynton have also never really heard Buddhists speak about Marx

273
00:30:33.790 --> 00:30:43.970
Winton: or someone who is interested in Marx adopt a Buddhist ethical kind of way of life. So for me, these 2 Venn diagrams coming together is a cause for joy.

274
00:30:43.980 --> 00:30:53.310
Winton: One question I've had on my lips for all Marx, or people who kind of subscribe to Marx is this problem of greed

275
00:30:54.130 --> 00:30:58.520
Winton: and the tragedy of Commons in particular. How does a system

276
00:30:59.380 --> 00:31:01.420
Winton: that Marx would

277
00:31:02.080 --> 00:31:13.340
Winton: agree with, or any kind of neo-marxist deal with the problem of me, taking more than I need because of some artificial scarcity, whether real or imagined.

278
00:31:14.160 --> 00:31:15.570
Winton: Well, I would.

279
00:31:16.790 --> 00:31:30.560
Winton: I would conjecture that greed originally arose. I got this idea. I must say, comes from Stephen in 2,004 that that really greed, hatred.

280
00:31:30.640 --> 00:31:33.460
Winton: and delusion. I

281
00:31:33.470 --> 00:31:35.980
Winton: evolutionary factors. We wouldn't.

282
00:31:36.030 --> 00:31:52.250
Winton: We wouldn't have been such a successful species if we hadn't had greed, hatred, and delusion. And greed. Greed is a is a response to insecurity. It's agreed to. It's it's, you know, if if you

283
00:31:52.330 --> 00:31:57.120
Winton: if you're worried about where your next meal is coming from. You're going to be greedy.

284
00:31:57.480 --> 00:32:00.489
Winton: But if you're living in in a society which

285
00:32:00.750 --> 00:32:16.069
Winton: is going to provide your next build. Anyway, you don't have to be anything like a greedy. You don't have to be greedy at all, and a lot of things that we are greedy about like private things that are privatized like

286
00:32:16.490 --> 00:32:23.859
Winton: transport, and and you know even health to some extent, if that's all, provided you wouldn't.

287
00:32:24.610 --> 00:32:28.450
Winton: you wouldn't need it, having lived in

288
00:32:28.500 --> 00:32:39.169
Winton: in Sweden in the heyday of its welfare status, could see this. I mean, a whole lot of young people just didn't want to buy a car because they didn't even want to get a license

289
00:32:39.350 --> 00:32:42.449
Winton: because they had a public transport system that worked.

290
00:32:42.540 --> 00:32:51.159
Winton: And and you know there was a real kind of rejection of consumerism going on because

291
00:32:51.240 --> 00:32:59.460
Winton: everything they really needed was going to be there anyway. A good health system, good education, free university. Why be greedy?

292
00:33:04.130 --> 00:33:08.039
Winton: Because they can. Okay, sorry.

293
00:33:08.180 --> 00:33:16.590
Winton: Yes, you said, why would they be greedy? And I say, because they can. You know, it's it's like everybody's bashing the system.

294
00:33:16.690 --> 00:33:19.770
Winton: holding up signs. It says, Down with capitalism

295
00:33:21.330 --> 00:33:24.550
Winton: when they should be holding up signs that say, down with greed.

296
00:33:25.240 --> 00:33:32.180
Winton: because I don't care what system you come up with? If if there is, why don't you call it free time

297
00:33:32.380 --> 00:33:40.590
Winton: free time? Okay. If you if that system were developed, you can bet that somebody will develop a market for free-time futures.

298
00:33:40.720 --> 00:33:48.309
Winton: Okay, it doesn't stop, you know. It's like everybody is pointing at the wrong in the wrong direction.

299
00:33:48.340 --> 00:33:59.340
Winton: and they should be pointing at developing morals, ethical standards at a much earlier age. showing showing the the effects of greed on production.

300
00:33:59.710 --> 00:34:07.720
Winton: on mental health and drill it into people. It's it's like.

301
00:34:10.080 --> 00:34:15.929
Winton: How do you stop greed? And it's and it's what causes all the systems to fail.

302
00:34:18.659 --> 00:34:24.809
Winton: Yeah. And I think that's really an argument from human nature. And I and I

303
00:34:25.219 --> 00:34:28.600
Winton: I feel extremely skeptical about any

304
00:34:28.980 --> 00:34:34.660
Winton: reference back to human nature. I mean, if we were all as essentially greedy as that.

305
00:34:34.929 --> 00:34:40.950
Winton: Why would there be gazillions of dollars spent on advertising to make us greedy?

306
00:34:41.130 --> 00:34:55.820
Winton: I mean, why wouldn't, if if we were all greedy. We we wouldn't need an advertising system to to sell goods. We'd be scrambling after them anyway. And the point is that that advertising is simply

307
00:34:55.840 --> 00:34:59.590
Winton: eggy new song is saying, you know that our lives are

308
00:34:59.990 --> 00:35:02.000
Winton: incomplete without

309
00:35:02.090 --> 00:35:15.580
Winton: the latest 6 cylinder, Suv, or whatever it is, it's not. And if if that idea was already in our heads. Then then the manufacturers of these things are wasting an awful lot of money on advertising.

310
00:35:22.430 --> 00:35:26.109
Winton: So it is.

311
00:35:26.580 --> 00:35:35.349
Winton: I mean, you've you've covered the whole of the whole world in in in in in 2 Si mean, it's so much

312
00:35:35.390 --> 00:35:37.689
Winton: to talk about.

313
00:35:38.740 --> 00:35:41.160
Winton: yeah,

314
00:35:41.220 --> 00:35:47.949
Winton: as somebody who spent 12 years on a kibbutz. and in my younger days

315
00:35:48.050 --> 00:35:53.979
Winton:  I've seen firsthand how this can work

316
00:35:54.040 --> 00:35:58.380
Winton: in a smaller society. Where.

317
00:35:58.500 --> 00:36:18.389
Winton: even though there is specialization in work because it's efficient, you still have to sow the crops. reap them, and and make a reasonable living out of it in order to provide the education and the health care and everything, and and the social amenities that the society has.

318
00:36:18.780 --> 00:36:26.530
Winton:  The mundane stuff was always distributed on a on a roster basis.

319
00:36:26.770 --> 00:36:32.869
Winton: so I would know that I would have my 3 months washing dishes every 5 years.

320
00:36:33.170 --> 00:36:37.110
Winton: But the so these kinds of things were were distributed.

321
00:36:37.910 --> 00:36:39.420
Winton: But

322
00:36:39.430 --> 00:36:52.019
Winton: how do you extrapolate, extrapolate outwards, and do that on the in the larger society all the experiments so far have failed, even though Scandinavian countries and Australia, to

323
00:36:52.170 --> 00:36:58.529
Winton: to a reasonable degree, has social welfare kind of

324
00:36:58.540 --> 00:37:02.000
Winton: legislation in place which compensates

325
00:37:02.920 --> 00:37:21.860
Winton:  But how you you you you move past Tim's basic greed. And I like the idea of having, you know, free time futures. So maybe the problem is, if you, if you turn it to morality becomes a thing that you maybe you've created. Morality futures.

326
00:37:22.110 --> 00:37:23.430
Winton: that the

327
00:37:23.620 --> 00:37:34.089
Winton: the ability to to advertise and to push products. And I like the fact that you said that they're only interested in what was the sales, not whether they were used or not.

328
00:37:34.420 --> 00:37:36.969
Winton: You probably read a book in the

329
00:37:37.120 --> 00:37:42.260
Winton: the 60 s. Called Design for the real World, by written by Viktor Papinik.

330
00:37:42.410 --> 00:37:51.720
Winton: who, he said that advertising design is there, and if I can remember it correctly to create

331
00:37:51.790 --> 00:37:53.270
Winton: a desire

332
00:37:53.340 --> 00:38:02.419
Winton: to buy something don't need to impress, and that you don't use that you won't use.

333
00:38:05.320 --> 00:38:05.980
Winton: Hmm.

334
00:38:08.010 --> 00:38:11.740
Winton: We've got a question online. We'll go to Leslie then. Yeah, Leslie.

335
00:38:11.810 --> 00:38:33.510
Lesley Synge: Oh, hello, everyone. Firstly, I'd just like to say my energy has been a bit scattered because I've actually been quite involved here in my zoom world, here in Brisbane, between labor for survival. And you know the work of actually thinking and meditating. I had a little family of mice die in my vacuum cleaner.

336
00:38:33.720 --> 00:38:39.839
Lesley Synge: and the smell was really strong. So I had to actually take some time out

337
00:38:40.340 --> 00:38:49.090
Lesley Synge: zipping back and forth. Just fixing that. So I actually emailed this this morning after Stevens

338
00:38:49.350 --> 00:38:51.870
Lesley Synge: session. And this is what I wrote.

339
00:38:52.990 --> 00:39:01.879
Lesley Synge: I look to Marx. He talked about alienation. When we are alienated from our labor, we suffer.

340
00:39:02.140 --> 00:39:06.099
Lesley Synge: And then I quote, in 1844,

341
00:39:06.180 --> 00:39:19.820
Lesley Synge: Marx said the worker, has a feeling of misery, not of well being is physically exhausted and mentally debased. As soon as there is no physical or other compulsion, work is avoided like the plague.

342
00:39:20.040 --> 00:39:22.190
Lesley Synge: So, Winton.

343
00:39:22.510 --> 00:39:31.820
Lesley Synge: I don't really know what question to ask, except to say, I think this is very important, that you publish something.

344
00:39:32.570 --> 00:39:38.699
Lesley Synge: something more about this whole area, you and Stephen, because I really think you're onto something.

345
00:39:38.720 --> 00:39:42.210
I'm just thinking also back to Stephen's

346
00:39:42.920 --> 00:39:44.770
Lesley Synge: dichotomy.

347
00:39:45.050 --> 00:39:53.899
Lesley Synge: If you think of the rice farmer laborers in the fields of Cambodia building ankle. What

348
00:39:54.040 --> 00:39:57.689
Lesley Synge: they were probably not that alienated from what they were doing.

349
00:39:57.950 --> 00:40:00.720
Lesley Synge: They weren't. I don't think, slaves.

350
00:40:00.880 --> 00:40:18.080
Lesley Synge: I think they were pleased to be doing some work for the King that they felt was meaningful. Well, this is all a bit of projection, but you know they weren't slave labor, as far as I understand. So therefore we're often not alienated from

351
00:40:18.340 --> 00:40:27.889
Lesley Synge: our our work. So it's a really fantastically rich field, and thanks very much for your contribution.

352
00:40:29.020 --> 00:40:30.209
Winton: Thank you, Lucy.

353
00:40:32.050 --> 00:40:44.379
Winton: Thanks, Swinton, fascinating! Just back to the point that Tim was raising there. I thought, I mean that the whole question of institutional change versus individual transformation.

354
00:40:44.570 --> 00:40:55.359
Winton: So that reminded me of the quote by EO. Wilson, the sociobiologist, which goes something like this, the problem with the world is that humans have

355
00:40:55.920 --> 00:40:58.030
Winton: cardiolic brains.

356
00:40:58.210 --> 00:41:04.210
Winton: We have medieval institutions and godlike technologies.

357
00:41:04.310 --> 00:41:07.809
Winton: What's your take on that?

358
00:41:09.470 --> 00:41:20.759
Winton: Well, look, I mean, I've already said, pretty averse to generalizations that seem to me to come back to human nature. I mean, we are

359
00:41:21.620 --> 00:41:29.480
Winton: very malleable creatures, and we and we're highly socialized. and it depends upon

360
00:41:29.610 --> 00:41:34.629
Winton: the you know what sort of society we're socialized into.

361
00:41:34.740 --> 00:41:39.770
Winton: If we're socialized into a society are

362
00:41:39.980 --> 00:41:46.579
Winton: based upon generosity and sharing and making sure everybody's needs are taken care of.

363
00:41:46.940 --> 00:41:49.949
Winton: Ii think we would.

364
00:41:50.110 --> 00:42:03.210
Winton: behave very differently to the way that we've been behaving under capitalism, and one of the one of the things. One of the many insights in Marx is

365
00:42:03.220 --> 00:42:06.109
Winton: that capitalism is the only

366
00:42:06.170 --> 00:42:12.599
Winton: mode of production in history which actually generates unemployment

367
00:42:12.910 --> 00:42:15.500
Winton: unemployment

368
00:42:15.740 --> 00:42:18.309
Winton: that it is. It is in

369
00:42:18.350 --> 00:42:27.239
Winton: it is. There always has to be what he called an industrial reserve reserve army, there to depress wages.

370
00:42:27.600 --> 00:42:32.520
Winton: you know workers have to be desperate. They're cut off from

371
00:42:32.640 --> 00:42:47.259
Winton: any direct access to a livelihood is thrown off the land. And the only way they can survive is by selling their labor, and they should do so on capitalist principles

372
00:42:47.380 --> 00:42:58.849
Winton: are under conditions of unemployment where they're competing against each other. I mean, this is, you can look that this is the argument going on right now in Australia about interest rates.

373
00:42:59.080 --> 00:43:05.679
Winton: that we've got an unemployment rate under 4%. And that is not enough.

374
00:43:05.700 --> 00:43:08.849
Winton: We need more people to be unemployed

375
00:43:08.970 --> 00:43:14.529
Winton: in order to bring down the level of inflation. So in this

376
00:43:14.560 --> 00:43:19.089
Winton: I mean being unemployed is a terrible situation to be in.

377
00:43:19.560 --> 00:43:25.030
Winton: And yet we need people to be in this situation for the system to keep going.

378
00:43:25.180 --> 00:43:34.379
Winton: So if we were in a society where that logic did not hold. We wouldn't be as desperate as we are now.

379
00:43:35.470 --> 00:43:46.410
Winton: so just quick! Follow up! So on Leonora's point the other day, if she could, she would give 2 appeals to people, the mindfulness pill and the compassion pill. So you you

380
00:43:46.920 --> 00:43:53.310
Winton: you don't think We will necessarily need to go down that path.

381
00:43:53.850 --> 00:43:58.120
Winton: No, perhaps we should.

382
00:43:58.270 --> 00:44:06.230
Winton: grateful coffee. Now I'll come back in half an hour. Follow-up discussion

383
00:44:06.610 --> 00:44:15.330
Winton: when we come back. Ayla has a question. So when we come back, Ayla can head off the conversation. Okay, great.

384
00:47:15.140 --> 00:47:17.169
Winton: I should make a comment, do you think?

385
00:47:17.320 --> 00:47:18.140
Be happy?

386
00:47:18.280 --> 00:47:20.760
Winton: Yeah, welcome back.

387
00:47:21.430 --> 00:47:22.829
Winton: and then we have

388
00:47:23.760 --> 00:47:28.130
Winton: Ayla. Is that right? I'll know the screen. Hmm! Right

389
00:47:32.590 --> 00:47:35.160
Ayla Curtis: unmute Rookie era.

390
00:47:35.520 --> 00:47:42.420
Ayla Curtis:  Hi, everybody! Hi, Winton! Thank you. For the amazing talk.

391
00:47:43.330 --> 00:48:05.949
Ayla Curtis: My question, I think, is about time, and I'll kind of wander my way there. But I wanted to start with David Graeber. Who? Who? Yeah, I found, really, I guess, quite inspirational. His writings in recent years. And I actually have a quote on my wall here that I take a lot of comfort from which, says the ultimate, hidden truth of the world, is that it is something

392
00:48:05.980 --> 00:48:09.489
Ayla Curtis: that we make, and we could just as easily make different

393
00:48:09.840 --> 00:48:23.029
Ayla Curtis:  which I find quite inspiring, because I think it goes back to this idea of of like imagination. So we've kind of imagined this system and through this shared imagining we've

394
00:48:23.390 --> 00:48:29.340
Ayla Curtis: supported it and encouraged it. and reading the dawn of everything.

395
00:48:30.000 --> 00:48:43.469
Ayla Curtis: I guess I really opened my eyes to this idea that this is a shared imagination that we've created and sort of it's been enforced by the system itself and the people in power to encourage it. So this idea of human nature being

396
00:48:43.640 --> 00:49:01.809
Ayla Curtis: inherently greedy like, I don't think is necessarily right like it certainly may be a part of it, but there's also this part of human nature that's inherently social and communi communal and and compassionate. So I struggle with I this idea that we focus on.

397
00:49:02.310 --> 00:49:06.440
Ayla Curtis: This greed is a big part of human nature rather than

398
00:49:06.810 --> 00:49:16.979
Ayla Curtis: the community side, and this compassionate side. And yet reading the dawn of everything was just really eye opening to me to see that we could imagine something different based on this

399
00:49:17.020 --> 00:49:27.790
Ayla Curtis: different flavor of humanity that's been so important and influential as well. It's just that we're kind of in this system that probably. you know, encourages and rewards.

400
00:49:28.340 --> 00:49:32.690
Ayla Curtis: greed and power. And some of these traits that maybe aren't so healthy.

401
00:49:32.950 --> 00:49:47.480
Ayla Curtis:  but it's kind of led me to kind of question my time, and where I can contribute to the world to sort of facilitate this shed, imagining into something different, and living more compassionately, which is where I guess the the dharma comes into it.

402
00:49:48.200 --> 00:49:54.870
Ayla Curtis: So for me, that sort of turned into a lot of personal practices and involvement in the Union movement, because that seems to be an

403
00:49:54.880 --> 00:50:05.359
Ayla Curtis: a movement or a group that's facilitated a lot of great social change in the past. But I guess my question is around, or one like.

404
00:50:06.470 --> 00:50:12.030
Ayla Curtis: why are we not focusing on this other side of humanity and this

405
00:50:12.210 --> 00:50:22.680
Ayla Curtis: these probably you know, these incredible traits of compassion and kindness that probably have contributed to human survival a lot more than greed in my humble opinion.

406
00:50:22.830 --> 00:50:26.709
Ayla Curtis:  and in your experience, linkedin-like.

407
00:50:27.600 --> 00:50:31.029
Ayla Curtis: where's like, where's a good place to put our time

408
00:50:31.640 --> 00:50:43.130
Ayla Curtis: to, I guess. Be really effective at that, to use some kind of wanky managerial terms, but you know, like my time is short and limited, I feel like in this time of crisis.

409
00:50:43.190 --> 00:50:50.550
Ayla Curtis: There's not a whole lot of time like there's this imperative behind it, and and kind of knowing what's going to be

410
00:50:51.110 --> 00:50:57.470
Ayla Curtis:  helpful, I guess, is is difficult, like there's so many ways to do it, and

411
00:50:57.530 --> 00:50:59.050
Ayla Curtis: it just seems like

412
00:51:00.580 --> 00:51:05.049
Ayla Curtis: there's not enough time to do that. So it's a bit of a tension for me.

413
00:51:06.850 --> 00:51:22.550
Ayla Curtis: yeah. So I don't know like what the question is around that, but for me it comes up as time like, where's an effective place to put my time to actually facilitate this shared imagining. And and we've spoken a lot about creativity and art which is so important. But then there's this sort of activist

414
00:51:22.770 --> 00:51:26.820
Ayla Curtis: role that we have to play as well, so gets a bit confusing.

415
00:51:29.160 --> 00:51:47.759
Winton: Yes. Oh, thanks for posing the question, however broad it is, I mean, I think it's a question, you know, where do we? Where do we put our time? Free time? We have, I think, right now it has to be. It has to be a priority for

416
00:51:48.770 --> 00:51:53.710
Winton: climate, action and environmental action in general, but also

417
00:51:54.010 --> 00:51:57.460
Winton:  the unbelievable

418
00:51:57.860 --> 00:52:00.230
Winton: level of

419
00:52:00.370 --> 00:52:13.660
Winton: relative deprivation and social exclusion in our own country, probably in our own suburbs, in our own cities. And of course, in the wider world, you know, the

420
00:52:13.690 --> 00:52:18.200
Winton: we really do have to think in terms of the global north and the global South.

421
00:52:18.610 --> 00:52:23.440
Winton: just things like buying a T-shirt, you know.

422
00:52:23.480 --> 00:52:35.689
Winton: there's this strange impulse to go and find the cheapest T-shirt. And without thinking about. You know the supply chain. It probably leads back to a sweatshop in

423
00:52:35.970 --> 00:52:41.119
Winton: somewhere like Bangladesh, where you know where one is sporting, appalling

424
00:52:41.240 --> 00:52:46.899
Winton: labor conditions. So I mean, part of it is just living more mindfully

425
00:52:47.250 --> 00:53:04.369
Winton: but also getting organized, I think, and and has to choose. This was, I guess, the message from Lenori session last night was, you know, you. You really need to choose where you're going to be effective. You can't be effective

426
00:53:04.380 --> 00:53:05.689
right across the board.

427
00:53:07.290 --> 00:53:17.270
Winton: And I think the other thing just from the way you started, was. I really think we need to be extremely skeptical about sourcing anything to do with

428
00:53:17.920 --> 00:53:22.329
Winton: human behavior in terms of some sort of human

429
00:53:22.480 --> 00:53:31.910
Winton: nature or human essence. You know, I mean, people in this society are peculiarly greedy and

430
00:53:31.970 --> 00:53:43.740
Winton: and indifferent, but when something happens like a like a a bush fire, you know you've got volunteer bush fires fighting in fire while their own homes are being burnt down.

431
00:53:43.830 --> 00:53:53.859
Winton: you know, 10 kilometers away, and you got all those heroic stories about what happened in the floods. So something is going on there. That's so.

432
00:53:53.960 --> 00:54:04.659
Winton: you know, slightly healthy, and and I think it really does depend upon as Marx himself said, you know, social being determines social consciousness.

433
00:54:04.830 --> 00:54:16.499
Winton: If we are living in. In a society with a strong community sense, then we are likely to to reach out to people who are in need.

434
00:54:16.810 --> 00:54:20.269
Winton: If we're living atonized lives in the big city.

435
00:54:20.320 --> 00:54:27.409
Winton: you know. We're we're we're fighting a war of all against all. Then we're probably

436
00:54:27.600 --> 00:54:28.810
Winton: going to

437
00:54:29.000 --> 00:54:36.319
Winton: revert back to good old dossier moral indifference about what you know. There, there.

438
00:54:36.960 --> 00:54:38.980
Predicament, whatever it is.

439
00:54:39.480 --> 00:54:40.840
Winton: Yeah. So

440
00:54:40.920 --> 00:54:45.459
Winton: skepticism about human nature, I think, is is also a good rule.

441
00:54:50.550 --> 00:55:05.829
Winton: I'm Carol. And so a couple of things, firstly, of this thing of free time, and I think in the early twentieth century Bertrand Russell wrote a little paper called in praise of Idleness.

442
00:55:05.940 --> 00:55:14.450
Winton: and it was the same thing, but he made the point that you have to have a certain level of wealth in order to be able to have free time.

443
00:55:14.560 --> 00:55:26.679
Winton: Sometimes looking around at how people use their free time, so much of it goes in watching TV and playing computer games and being spectators rather than acting like, you know, kind of makes you wonder.

444
00:55:27.090 --> 00:55:38.810
Winton: But the other thing I wanted to say was. I think it was 2,014. Naomi Klein wrote a book called This Changes everything, and it was her argument

445
00:55:38.860 --> 00:55:41.750
Winton: that you cannot

446
00:55:41.880 --> 00:55:59.050
Winton: address the climate crisis without changing the neoliberal fundamentalism and industrial capitalism. And the whole book is the argument about, you know, basically, if you don't change the system, you don't achieve anything.

447
00:55:59.100 --> 00:56:10.840
Winton: And so where do we put our time? And yes, you know eat less meat and drive an efficient car. But to be effective, we have to change the system.

448
00:56:11.510 --> 00:56:13.730
Winton: And if you think of

449
00:56:13.910 --> 00:56:41.890
Winton: the single State capture where your very wealthy corporations now basically have captured government, so why hasn't our left wing. Government banned all coal mines and its state captures because these huge organizations have too much influence on them. The only way to break that I see is activism in getting together and looking at the.

450
00:56:41.900 --> 00:56:45.640
Winton: at the organisations that really are

451
00:56:45.680 --> 00:56:59.460
Winton: doing such a good job and join those, you know, 350.org, or the Climate Council or extinction rebellion, and so that we can kind of get this mass volume of people

452
00:56:59.570 --> 00:57:06.309
Winton: enough to change to change the system, because without that I don't think we're gonna get anywhere.

453
00:57:08.800 --> 00:57:16.289
Winton: It's important to start building counterinstitutions. Also, I mean a growth in

454
00:57:16.470 --> 00:57:31.350
Winton: the cooperative movement would be a good way to go, for instance, I mean because cooperatives they're not driven by the profit motive. But it's also in terms of mobilisation mobilising against

455
00:57:31.400 --> 00:57:33.150
Winton: the most tired.

456
00:57:33.420 --> 00:57:40.059
Winton: the most dangerous aspects of the system. It's also interesting to

457
00:57:40.230 --> 00:57:42.340
Winton: pick up the

458
00:57:42.700 --> 00:57:56.150
Winton: The dissidents from the system are known as Twiggy Forest Town. said yesterday that anyone there's still digging up coal and gas has blood on their hands. I mean, this is coming from it.

459
00:57:56.490 --> 00:58:04.679
Winton: Know a mining name. It's it's just amazing. So I think it's also important to kind of

460
00:58:05.180 --> 00:58:10.520
Winton: prize off like oysters, you know. Prize them off the system like that.

461
00:58:12.230 --> 00:58:13.290
Winton: Thank you.

462
00:58:14.870 --> 00:58:20.839
Winton:  Part of this, I think, is changing the way the story is told.

463
00:58:21.030 --> 00:58:27.940
Winton: You can have the same events happen, and with one set of reporting. They go nowhere.

464
00:58:28.100 --> 00:58:40.389
Winton: and with another set of reporting they seem either quite counter cultural or the start of something or a significant challenge. So one of the things. One of the areas that I think is

465
00:58:40.580 --> 00:58:55.530
Winton: is important in developing and not yet developed is how we build a bridge between the very high level ideas that you were talking about initially. and the way in which we want the changes that are happening and the things that are occurring

466
00:58:55.560 --> 00:58:58.450
Winton: to be reported and heard and understood.

467
00:58:58.840 --> 00:59:05.489
Winton: and there was a really good example here which was the earlier mention of the tragedy of the Commons.

468
00:59:06.110 --> 00:59:14.139
Winton: Now the true story of the tragedy of the Commons is, it was a flip phrase which was invented, I think, in the 1970 S.

469
00:59:14.260 --> 00:59:21.350
Winton: And took off because it was a nice, neat phrase, and it fitted into the capitalist mindset and what they wanted to believe.

470
00:59:21.800 --> 00:59:23.810
There's a one called Ruth Ostroff.

471
00:59:23.860 --> 00:59:33.970
Winton: who got the Nobel Prize for Economics in 2,016 for a lifetime's work, in showing that there was no tragedy of the Commons.

472
00:59:34.100 --> 00:59:50.410
Winton: that there were, in fact, at least 10 quite distinct different ways in which Commons had been managed very successfully, and described the kind of rules that you needed around them, in order for them to succeed.

473
00:59:51.270 --> 01:00:03.430
Winton: Problem. There was not anyone could have got that knowledge. The problem was the phrase. The tragedy of the Commons came out of the blue. And suddenly someone had to spend a lifetime's work undoing that mischief.

474
01:00:03.740 --> 01:00:24.180
Winton: So I think the way we tell the stories and books like the graver book are very helpful, because they give echoes that we can riff off as we tell the stories, and we can say, of course, if you say I've done this in conversation. Sometimes you say, of course, what happened in the Iroquois was

475
01:00:24.710 --> 01:00:33.879
Winton: when you want to introduce something quite different. And people are really interested because it's all a bit exotic or something, whereas if you bring out some kind of hypothetical

476
01:00:34.770 --> 01:00:36.639
Winton: they think it's just

477
01:00:36.690 --> 01:00:37.740
Winton: dreaming.

478
01:00:37.920 --> 01:00:40.150
Winton: So somehow.

479
01:00:40.560 --> 01:00:47.880
Winton: there's still a big task, I think, in linking the high level to the low level, to the action. And I guess I'm wanting to highlight

480
01:00:48.480 --> 01:00:55.149
Winton: importance of the way we tell the stories, and I don't know if you've got any comments or good examples of that. But

481
01:00:56.760 --> 01:01:00.720
Winton:  well, I mean, there is certainly

482
01:01:00.740 --> 01:01:08.019
Winton: one of the things I'm I'm I'm really surprised at is how few people have picked up the Mondragon

483
01:01:09.480 --> 01:01:16.899
Winton: system. Mondragon, in northern Spain is the whole region which is

484
01:01:17.230 --> 01:01:19.379
run on cooperative lives.

485
01:01:19.460 --> 01:01:21.000
Winton: So you've got like, you know.

486
01:01:21.230 --> 01:01:38.270
Winton: So several industries, some of them, which can export and and it's all owned by the people who live there. There's no ex. There's no external capital. They've got their own bank. You can have a cooperative bank, I mean, because

487
01:01:38.810 --> 01:01:49.639
Winton: productive enterprises require external finance from time to time, and if you can get it from a bank that is working in the same cooperative system instead of

488
01:01:49.740 --> 01:01:51.230
Winton: a capitalist system.

489
01:01:51.450 --> 01:02:00.860
Winton: Then, you know, you can sustain this over time. Now, you know, most people haven't heard of Mondragon, but it's a really big deal. It's a

490
01:02:01.010 --> 01:02:02.330
Winton: I mean, I

491
01:02:03.020 --> 01:02:13.160
Winton: it's a while since I checked in. But it there were about 90,000 people living in that area and living in this way. So you know, they weren't all

492
01:02:13.790 --> 01:02:31.650
Winton: counter cultural hippies, and I mean they were technicians and and industrial workers and so forth. So I mean, I think that bringing forward. Those kinds of those kinds of examples is really good, and and also the

493
01:02:32.760 --> 01:02:36.609
Winton:  What this was mentioning

494
01:02:36.780 --> 01:02:39.049
Winton: a Kibbutz is always on a

495
01:02:39.210 --> 01:02:42.150
Winton: visited a kibbutz in

496
01:02:42.340 --> 01:02:49.190
Winton: 2,000 that was making really high tech stuff, you know, and and exporting

497
01:02:49.610 --> 01:02:52.819
Winton: and but it was still

498
01:02:53.320 --> 01:02:58.539
Winton: a Kabuz was still running on those sort of cooperative lines at a time when

499
01:02:58.780 --> 01:03:11.209
Winton: a lot of kibbutzim were were collapsing because they got too much into debt. And and you know the bankers took over and and they couldn't keep going. But this one was

500
01:03:11.240 --> 01:03:14.010
Winton: really successful, you know, was, it shows how

501
01:03:15.280 --> 01:03:20.290
Winton: you know productive efficiency can work just as well under non capitalist conditions.

502
01:03:22.410 --> 01:03:24.790
Winton: We've got Linda online.

503
01:03:25.790 --> 01:03:26.490
Winton: Hi.

504
01:03:26.840 --> 01:03:28.240
Lynda: Hi, everyone!

505
01:03:28.440 --> 01:03:58.149
Lynda: Hi, Wynden! Look! First of all, I'd just like to acknowledge and express some gratefulness to everyone. Engaged in this very inspirational discussion and process. It's been wonderful, it I feel as I've been in an intellectual desert for years, and to gallop back through time into the various histories and personalities has been just so richly rewarding. It's been wonderful.

506
01:03:58.150 --> 01:04:05.879
Lynda: I guess the the comment I want to make, and also then it raises the question, so the comment is,

507
01:04:06.150 --> 01:04:34.220
Lynda: yes, there's so much to do. We we, from what people have expressed and outlined, we are all to varying degrees of emphasis, very aware of what the problem is. We also have outlined very clearly some of the the different approaches that may be complementary while tolerating, you know, differences of opinion

508
01:04:35.300 --> 01:04:52.290
Lynda: for me, listening to people's earnest plea, for how do we deal with the magnitude and implement many of the solutions, the magnitude of the problem, and many of the solutions

509
01:04:52.340 --> 01:05:04.009
Lynda: that are quite practical, but need to overcome so many barriers. And one of the critical things that stand out to me is control of information.

510
01:05:04.590 --> 01:05:10.750
Lynda: communication, misinformation.

511
01:05:10.760 --> 01:05:33.179
Lynda: governments captured by capital. Yes. Huge problem. honesty in politics significant issue. But I draw on my experience of being intensely engaged with the recent referendum, particularly in the last 2 weeks, where I spent many hours a day.

512
01:05:33.720 --> 01:05:39.690
Lynda: actively campaigning. Now this was over 40,000 volunteers

513
01:05:40.030 --> 01:06:00.389
Lynda: engaging widely, you know, round kitchen table conversations right into telephoning into enemy territory. Analysis of the results when the dust was settled, showed that 51% of Australians actually voted in favour, and this was, despite

514
01:06:00.690 --> 01:06:09.560
Lynda: a heavy biased campaign against the positive aspects of what a yes vote would bring.

515
01:06:10.660 --> 01:06:19.119
Lynda: That whole issue was basically sabotaged through misinformation and lack of control

516
01:06:19.190 --> 01:06:25.170
Lynda: over information. And so my question is and we may not.

517
01:06:25.500 --> 01:06:35.929
Lynda: I suspect we'll we'll go back over the same ground. Of how do we address this? Because it we seem to have lost this fight.

518
01:06:39.210 --> 01:06:43.370
Winton: Yes. Well, you've certainly named a major problem.

519
01:06:43.460 --> 01:06:54.990
Winton: particularly in this country, where about, I think, about 87% of the mass media is owned by the Murdoch mob

520
01:06:55.120 --> 01:06:57.480
Winton: and

521
01:06:57.490 --> 01:07:00.239
Winton: So you know, we

522
01:07:00.300 --> 01:07:06.770
Winton: we grimly have to defend what is not Murdoch, ie. The ABC. And to some extent

523
01:07:07.450 --> 01:07:12.670
Winton: the former Fairfax media. But

524
01:07:12.700 --> 01:07:19.350
Winton: and and I certainly think there should be. Yeah, we should be clamoring for much tighter controls on social media in terms of

525
01:07:19.540 --> 01:07:23.880
Winton: spreading disinformation, hate, speech, and all the rest of it.

526
01:07:25.230 --> 01:07:32.440
Winton: Some. There's also a basic problem of education, I think, behind.

527
01:07:32.610 --> 01:07:35.240
Winton: But you know, to taking an example of the

528
01:07:35.820 --> 01:07:42.770
Winton: observe of the referendum, and it sort of falls a bit outside what we're talking about here at the moment. But

529
01:07:42.840 --> 01:07:46.500
Winton: the fact, I think, that the vast majority of

530
01:07:46.640 --> 01:07:50.450
Winton: Australians haven't. The faintest idea

531
01:07:50.490 --> 01:07:54.849
Winton: are what the historical sources of

532
01:07:55.420 --> 01:07:57.610
Winton: indigenous disadvantage are.

533
01:07:58.190 --> 01:08:00.100
Winton: And you know it.

534
01:08:00.250 --> 01:08:04.689
Winton: It's it's still people are horrified when you talk about

535
01:08:05.160 --> 01:08:23.380
Winton: the aboriginal genocide, when it when what happened here is so clearly within the definition of genocide in the 1948 UN Convention on it. And so until, and what was interesting about the the

536
01:08:23.689 --> 01:08:28.680
Winton: both the yes and the no campaign. Neither of them mention that

537
01:08:28.880 --> 01:08:30.589
Winton: it was as if

538
01:08:30.609 --> 01:08:36.860
Winton: you know, our indigenous disadvantages had no had no back story.

539
01:08:36.880 --> 01:08:49.459
Winton: It was just something that was happening right now. And until we get through until people understand the back story. We're not going to get another kind of result

540
01:08:49.640 --> 01:08:52.870
Winton: if this ever comes up again, which is probably

541
01:08:53.010 --> 01:09:11.899
Winton: are probably unlikely. And part of the problem. Part of that problem is also that 48% of Australians were either born overseas or had one parent who was born overseas and who have a very and probably the vast majority would have a very shallow idea of

542
01:09:11.939 --> 01:09:17.260
Winton: of the historical process that we are.

543
01:09:17.560 --> 01:09:21.389
Winton: that that that has produced what we have now. So

544
01:09:21.770 --> 01:09:28.049
Winton: anyway, that's it's a bit of a diversion for what we're talking about, but it but it does illustrate the fact that

545
01:09:28.960 --> 01:09:30.829
Winton: you know, I suppose.

546
01:09:31.160 --> 01:09:32.669
Winton: first and foremost.

547
01:09:33.029 --> 01:09:46.420
Winton: that it is a fundamental problem that that you know, an outlandish, far-right outfit like the Murdoch Knob, runs 87% of our mass media.

548
01:09:50.120 --> 01:09:53.920
Winton: We've got Steven over here.

549
01:09:55.400 --> 01:10:03.449
Winton:  I'd like to offer another metaphor for how we might frame this

550
01:10:03.780 --> 01:10:10.679
Winton: discussion, and particularly focusing on climate change. And that is the metaphor of a jujitsu.

551
01:10:11.670 --> 01:10:16.550
Winton: of turning the opponent's strength against

552
01:10:17.370 --> 01:10:18.719
Winton: him or herself

553
01:10:19.590 --> 01:10:24.539
Winton: using the power of the opposition to undermine the opposition.

554
01:10:25.480 --> 01:10:28.090
Winton: And this

555
01:10:28.470 --> 01:10:42.960
Winton: idea was first sparked in my mind by an essay I read last year by Bill Mckibben. He's an environmentalist writer who often appears in the pages of the New York Review of books which I

556
01:10:43.070 --> 01:10:45.040
Winton: read somewhat religiously

557
01:10:45.350 --> 01:10:48.320
Winton: and usually his. You know he's, you know.

558
01:10:48.430 --> 01:10:50.879
Winton: telling us what a terrible situation we're in.

559
01:10:51.960 --> 01:10:58.809
Winton: But in this essay he admitted that he saw a sign for optimism.

560
01:10:59.880 --> 01:11:05.490
Winton: and that was because he started to observe that more

561
01:11:05.530 --> 01:11:10.140
Winton: and more investment is going into green technologies

562
01:11:11.190 --> 01:11:21.430
Winton: that the price and the cost of solar panels, and so forth and so on, is going down, down, down. This is how capitalism works.

563
01:11:22.020 --> 01:11:23.570
And

564
01:11:23.750 --> 01:11:26.310
Winton: Mckibben was suggesting that

565
01:11:26.470 --> 01:11:35.479
Winton: where the push really needs to go, and I think a lot of what everyone is talking about here is pushing in the right direction, but perhaps not

566
01:11:35.970 --> 01:11:39.760
Winton: noticing that where the the tipping point

567
01:11:40.200 --> 01:11:48.780
Winton: might be. And this is the term Mckibben uses an economical tipping point, a capitalist tipping point

568
01:11:49.220 --> 01:11:51.400
Winton: where, in other words.

569
01:11:51.660 --> 01:11:56.419
Winton: instead of bemoaning the fact that these people have the profit motive.

570
01:11:56.430 --> 01:12:04.999
Winton: actually recognizing that that's where you can do the jujitsu turn. you actually make the green

571
01:12:05.500 --> 01:12:27.469
Winton: technologies, industries and so on. Profitable. Yeah. And if you the more that that happens, and this happens by many, it happens on governments putting more and more constraints on fossil fossil fuel emissions, and so on. It happens because of people out on the street campaigning against it. It happens, because of critiques of the kind of society we live in, and so forth, and so on.

572
01:12:27.770 --> 01:12:34.859
Winton: Mckibben felt that we might accelerate towards that tipping point.

573
01:12:35.040 --> 01:12:38.679
Winton: maybe sooner than we might have expected.

574
01:12:38.810 --> 01:12:42.589
Winton: and I was reading on the BBC news just this morning.

575
01:12:42.840 --> 01:12:48.369
Winton: How the the cost of of solar panels in particular, take particular, is dropping. The

576
01:12:48.590 --> 01:13:09.269
Winton: increase in use and demand for electric cars is rising, that there's many indicators that are are accelerating towards a kind of change. But the real point of change will be when the capitalists who hold all of the into the finance sector decide that fossil fuels are no longer going to be profitable.

577
01:13:09.630 --> 01:13:13.310
Winton: and at that point they'll start investing, and even the

578
01:13:13.720 --> 01:13:26.369
Winton: fossil fuel companies themselves, perhaps, and this picks up on Bernard's point that he raised a few days ago that we need to get the polluters to switch their investments from fossil fuels into

579
01:13:26.530 --> 01:13:28.020
Winton: other technologies.

580
01:13:28.980 --> 01:13:46.019
Winton: Again, I wouldn't assume that this is just going to happen as a matter of course. I don't think it will unless pressures are exerted. But however awful the capitalist system, as we have it, might be neoliberalism. So on do we given the urgency

581
01:13:46.460 --> 01:13:54.000
Winton: a matter of a few years? Do we have the luxury of being able to envision alternative economic systems

582
01:13:54.020 --> 01:14:04.360
Winton: rather than acknowledging that the present one is going to be for around and trying to use its logic to subvert it.

583
01:14:08.440 --> 01:14:12.140
Winton: What what you say to that?

584
01:14:12.290 --> 01:14:21.450
Winton:  I think one would be waiting longer for capitalism to reform itself than actually

585
01:14:21.700 --> 01:14:25.100
Winton: introducing something new at

586
01:14:25.120 --> 01:14:31.919
Winton: one of the one of the values of Marx's work was to think in terms of how

587
01:14:32.280 --> 01:14:41.510
Winton: socioeconomic systems change. So he had. His historical model was that there is a basic relationship between

588
01:14:41.690 --> 01:14:44.109
Winton: the direct workers.

589
01:14:44.840 --> 01:14:57.610
Winton: the means of production that they use, whether it's agricultural land or machinery and and and the machinery itself. So it's it's it's 3

590
01:14:58.060 --> 01:15:09.080
Winton: 3 groups that are in in this relationship. So you know his thematic account of

591
01:15:09.220 --> 01:15:15.649
Winton: historical changes that humans began with what he called primitive communism, in other words.

592
01:15:15.890 --> 01:15:30.080
Winton: tribal groups where there were no classes, to slave society, where certain people made other people into their private property and made them work

593
01:15:30.880 --> 01:15:36.250
Winton: to feudalism where you had, I mean, in in all these class

594
01:15:36.320 --> 01:15:53.190
Winton: societies it was always the property in the means of production that gave the ruling class its power. So in so in feudalism, you had the feudal barons and lords who owned the land, and and let it out for

595
01:15:53.240 --> 01:15:56.150
Winton: rent or rent in natura

596
01:15:56.260 --> 01:16:07.010
Winton: to the serfs or the peasants. And then you have capitalism. Where again, you've got a ruling class that doesn't work, but in control of

597
01:16:07.240 --> 01:16:13.129
Winton: the means of production, and and the direct workers are

598
01:16:14.030 --> 01:16:16.259
are excluded from control

599
01:16:16.400 --> 01:16:23.060
Winton: of the means of production that they themselves set in motion. So

600
01:16:23.170 --> 01:16:32.629
Winton: What Hegeland is is suggesting. And in fact, many other sorts of Socialists is, if you, if you put

601
01:16:32.700 --> 01:16:35.569
Winton: the actual workers in control

602
01:16:35.620 --> 01:16:40.009
Winton: of their of the means of production, then

603
01:16:40.190 --> 01:16:41.670
Winton: classes will

604
01:16:41.980 --> 01:16:45.220
Winton: will erode, because there's no longer

605
01:16:45.970 --> 01:16:55.909
Winton: a ruling class that that owns and controls the means of production. And but what what is is significant? Here is the hinge points.

606
01:16:56.050 --> 01:17:08.410
Winton: You know that they are that they are long historical processes. Capitalism really began about the thirteenth century in the Italian city states, but it didn't really go anywhere

607
01:17:08.700 --> 01:17:19.290
Winton: until until the beginnings of agricultural capitalism in in England with wool trade.

608
01:17:19.530 --> 01:17:23.290
And eventually, of course, industrial capitalism comes, and

609
01:17:23.410 --> 01:17:28.910
Winton: capitalism then consolidates as a world system. Now these transitions take

610
01:17:29.330 --> 01:17:41.339
Winton: a long time, but while the transition is going, the old system is gradually disintegrating, and the new system is gradually crystallising.

611
01:17:41.590 --> 01:17:47.369
Winton: and I think that some, that kind of idea of transitional periods

612
01:17:47.380 --> 01:17:49.830
Winton: is what should be the kind of

613
01:17:50.530 --> 01:17:52.630
Winton: the the.

614
01:17:52.730 --> 01:18:01.730
Winton: the, the global pattern that we're looking for. So sure, you know, if we can get capitalists to

615
01:18:02.610 --> 01:18:14.770
Winton: to invest in green technology, etc. That's great. We're going to need everything we we can get our hands on to overcome this crisis because it's really on top of us.

616
01:18:15.140 --> 01:18:21.179
Winton: But at the same time we can start developing. It's not a question of switching off

617
01:18:21.220 --> 01:18:38.379
Winton: this particular mode of production and turning the other one on. There's this transition period, and I think I mean agreeing with Wolf going straight, that I talked about earlier, that that neoliberalism, neoliberal capitalism, is on the ropes.

618
01:18:38.570 --> 01:18:55.349
Winton: and but it's going to take a long time before the transition works its way through, and how it works its way through is going to be in the development of of things like cooperation, cooperatives, ways of

619
01:18:55.690 --> 01:18:57.140
Winton: reorganizing

620
01:18:57.230 --> 01:19:00.920
Winton: both production and distribution.

621
01:19:01.650 --> 01:19:06.450
Winton: Unless I'm very skeptical about the idea of

622
01:19:07.090 --> 01:19:07.970
of

623
01:19:08.300 --> 01:19:14.709
Winton: green capitalism, because while, while there are going to be important examples of that, like

624
01:19:15.000 --> 01:19:28.719
Winton: dear old twiggy forest in Western Australia and his hydrogen plant. That's that's important. I mean. Everything's important that's going to make a difference. But it seems to me that it's not an eitherall proposition.

625
01:19:29.110 --> 01:19:33.470
Winton: do we? And a lot of the things we have to do

626
01:19:34.300 --> 01:19:35.430
will be

627
01:19:35.540 --> 01:19:38.220
Winton: post capitalist if you like.

628
01:19:39.120 --> 01:19:43.909
Winton: I think it'll be really dangerous for us to wait until

629
01:19:44.980 --> 01:19:46.369
Winton: whole lot of people

630
01:19:46.430 --> 01:19:51.220
Winton: who are extremely rich, decide. They can become even richer

631
01:19:51.280 --> 01:19:59.720
Winton: by investing in green technology. There aren't going to be many examples of that. And at the moment

632
01:20:00.290 --> 01:20:05.200
Winton: fossil fuels, fossil fuel industries are hugely powerful

633
01:20:05.230 --> 01:20:11.040
Winton: and hugely powerful on on the in terms of

634
01:20:11.070 --> 01:20:13.049
Winton: public persuasion. You know we've got

635
01:20:13.330 --> 01:20:20.019
Winton: a ha cop going on conference parties going on. As I said before, in a Petro state.

636
01:20:20.210 --> 01:20:26.110
and the chairman is saying, there is no scientific evidence. To suggest there's anything wrong with

637
01:20:26.130 --> 01:20:28.849
Winton: digging up more coal and gas. I mean, this is

638
01:20:29.210 --> 01:20:31.880
Winton: this is the power problem we've got

639
01:20:33.160 --> 01:20:38.260
Winton: or on it. He's actually with qualified and withdrawn that statement.

640
01:20:39.090 --> 01:20:43.500
Winton: Say he's qualified and withdrawn now, has he? Oh, let's go. Yeah.

641
01:20:44.100 --> 01:20:45.230
Winton: Hmm.

642
01:20:46.540 --> 01:20:53.530
Winton: all right, we've got question. Q. 1, 2, 3, 4. So Vivian online.

643
01:20:54.190 --> 01:21:05.909
Vivien Langford: Oh, yes, Wynton. I'm just glad you said it's on the ropes, because I was just going to draw your attention back to that. You said that I think on day. One neoliberalism is, the project is on the ropes.

644
01:21:06.010 --> 01:21:10.400
Vivien Langford: but I want to know how to push it towards collapse. You know that

645
01:21:10.450 --> 01:21:29.460
Vivien Langford: not the whole system, not everything, but because that frightens people, but the parts of it that are manipulating us. I went to a webinar with Scott, Ludlam, and some people who are all working on these various think tanks that manipulate opinion, and go and brought this thing. But the narrative.

646
01:21:29.460 --> 01:21:43.969
Vivien Langford: the Overton window, is another thing that was invented to just beguile us and change our our thinking about things. But it wastes a lot of time, and there's something called the Atlas network of groups, you know.

647
01:21:43.990 --> 01:22:00.499
Vivien Langford: including Murdoch, Media, and so on, that can unseat governments that can play on libertarian sentiments, and so on. And a lot of people just read about this in the present. Just so worrying. Meanwhile, at the Climate Action Group level that I

648
01:22:00.550 --> 01:22:02.739
Vivien Langford: sort of work on all the time.

649
01:22:02.950 --> 01:22:13.669
Vivien Langford: II feel. People feel that mass mobilization like we saw at Newcastle, the coal port, Mass mobilization, 2,000 people this year, 10,000 next year. That sort of thing people feel

650
01:22:13.960 --> 01:22:16.719
Vivien Langford: surely that will disrupt. That will push

651
01:22:16.840 --> 01:22:20.390
Vivien Langford: but I feel it has to be a little bit more

652
01:22:21.380 --> 01:22:42.440
Vivien Langford: entering the corridors of power, and I liked your story about Mac Machiavelli with you know, being very flattering to Cesare Borgia, and having his man at the back on a horse rushing off in the night with the total revelation about what was happening in that court. Well, I would like to have a

653
01:22:42.440 --> 01:22:53.039
Vivien Langford: know somebody inside those cough meetings with Sultan Al Jaber and the others in those secret meetings, because not even journalists are anywhere near that.

654
01:22:53.040 --> 01:23:17.549
Vivien Langford: and have some one with a horse out the back to leak it all to the press, so that we can get an idea of their strategy. Because from the Scotland, Webinar, he said, these people are so they put so much money into strategy. Whether it's advertising disinformation memes, it's very well cashed up and savvied, and we are still at the level of.

655
01:23:17.900 --> 01:23:25.680
Vivien Langford: you know, going around with placards and massing in numbers and saying, This is people power? Ii just feel

656
01:23:26.210 --> 01:23:36.739
Vivien Langford: I'd like some examples from you, not just the alternative, like Mondragon and the Kibbutz. But what are some ways and strategies that that you think through history have worked?

657
01:23:40.250 --> 01:23:47.290
Winton: I don't think I can produce more persuasive

658
01:23:47.370 --> 01:23:55.389
Winton: ideas of that, except I mean you there. Any any examples I can give would be

659
01:23:55.550 --> 01:24:03.699
Winton: pretty minor in comparison to the the the enormity of of the task. But I was just

660
01:24:03.770 --> 01:24:08.000
Winton: in the tea break, I mean, I was thinking about one at one time

661
01:24:09.270 --> 01:24:16.599
Winton: in Sweden when when I was doing research there. There was a real push back by the

662
01:24:16.790 --> 01:24:24.569
Winton: labor movement, which is stronger, was the strongest labor movement in the world at the time against

663
01:24:25.180 --> 01:24:26.400
against

664
01:24:26.600 --> 01:24:30.219
Winton:  you know, alienated labor.

665
01:24:30.340 --> 01:24:38.270
Winton: And and they began to experiment in getting rid of assembly lines. And, for instance, in in A

666
01:24:38.280 --> 01:24:55.210
Winton: in one or 2 of the Volvo factories. They got rid of the the Assembly line and and set up production teams, and then they just gave these production teams all the bits and pieces you need to make at motorcar and said, just do it any way you want.

667
01:24:55.280 --> 01:25:04.879
Winton: and you can swap jobs any way you like, and we'll provide you. We'll provide skill development, you know. If somebody gets sick of

668
01:25:05.590 --> 01:25:11.259
Winton: bolting on the bamboo bar, they can, you know, learn to

669
01:25:11.640 --> 01:25:20.549
Winton: to program the engine and things like that. So that that was that was a very successful experiment.

670
01:25:20.640 --> 01:25:21.680
Winton: and.

671
01:25:22.210 --> 01:25:41.380
Winton: strangely enough, increased productivity. But then along comes neoliberalism. It's all all over Red Rover. There's no more of that going on anymore. So, but that's an example of where you can work against the the logic of the system. But you've got to have.

672
01:25:41.990 --> 01:25:48.490
Winton: as Machiavelli would say, you know. You can't be a prophet unarmed. You've got to have

673
01:25:48.660 --> 01:25:52.990
Winton: real muscle, which is what the union movement had there.

674
01:25:53.140 --> 01:25:58.280
Winton: It really does take a countervailing force to get that sort of sort of thing up.

675
01:25:58.540 --> 01:26:06.729
Vivien Langford: Yeah. And there's a very strong, nonviolent, direct action. Ethos. And we're here to talk about ethical

676
01:26:08.260 --> 01:26:16.290
Vivien Langford: ethical behaviour in our lives, how we live our lives, taking on some of these parts of the crisis. I just

677
01:26:16.690 --> 01:26:21.029
Vivien Langford: want to know a bit more about if something's crumbling, if it's on the ropes.

678
01:26:21.380 --> 01:26:24.569
Vivien Langford: where's the best way to put our action to push it over.

679
01:26:25.200 --> 01:26:34.470
Winton: But I mean the point of it being on their ropes is that a lot of its goals have been lost like one of its great goals, was small government.

680
01:26:34.550 --> 01:26:42.919
Winton: you know, and this is the whole business of austerity policies which we've seen in, particularly in

681
01:26:43.170 --> 01:26:54.680
Winton: in Britain. And here and all around the world. You know that. Suddenly it was. You couldn't do that anymore, because everything collapsed in 2,008,

682
01:26:54.720 --> 01:26:59.690
Winton: and the government. The State had to step in and massively.

683
01:26:59.950 --> 01:27:01.920
Winton: massively shore up

684
01:27:02.090 --> 01:27:06.390
Winton: the banking systems around the world. So suddenly

685
01:27:06.590 --> 01:27:12.119
Winton: governments had enormous public debts, and then, and then the pandemic came along.

686
01:27:12.130 --> 01:27:27.349
Winton: and and again the State was hugely involved in preventing social catastrophe in that. So nobody talks about small government any more, because it doesn't mean anything.

687
01:27:27.390 --> 01:27:29.859
Winton: You can't have a small government anymore.

688
01:27:29.940 --> 01:27:34.520
Winton: So in that way, you know, the the wheels are falling off.

689
01:27:35.060 --> 01:27:44.560
Winton: and maybe I'm sort of coming back into convergence with what Stephen was saying, that that

690
01:27:44.660 --> 01:27:48.010
Winton: the system is weakened. A lot of its logic

691
01:27:48.150 --> 01:28:00.100
Winton: is is unworkable just on its own terms. So if the State is back, if Big business, if if the big State is back, then this is a time to push

692
01:28:00.240 --> 01:28:03.719
Winton: to whatever quasi-democratic means. We have

693
01:28:03.780 --> 01:28:06.809
Winton: to get the State on side, too, and try, and

694
01:28:06.920 --> 01:28:10.019
Winton: I detach it from the

695
01:28:10.210 --> 01:28:11.750
Winton: from the

696
01:28:11.890 --> 01:28:21.260
Winton: influence of things like, you know, fossil fuel industries. After all, you know the precedent for these, for

697
01:28:22.170 --> 01:28:30.590
Winton: the fossil fuel industry campaign to keep its business running is is big tobacco. When we were

698
01:28:31.070 --> 01:28:33.150
Winton: when we were banning

699
01:28:33.420 --> 01:28:48.140
Winton: smoking products and trying to cut down on on people smoking. I mean it. It really did cut into their profits. And they really did fight back hugely, pretending, you know, that they'd invented a cigarette that didn't cause

700
01:28:48.460 --> 01:28:52.969
that didn't cause cancer that had magical filters in their cigarettes.

701
01:28:53.000 --> 01:29:20.260
Winton: That meant they were no longer kind of carcinogenic, every trick in the trade. And this is what we're seeing again with fossil fuel industries, you know. They're probably going to invent a fossil fuel that actually decreases the amount of carbon in the air next tomorrow. But that's what we up against. I mean a really slippery and extremely well resourced

702
01:29:21.440 --> 01:29:25.359
Winton: opponent. Can I? Can I jump in here? There's

703
01:29:25.720 --> 01:29:49.700
Winton: There's a pathway that takes Steven's ji jitsu move of kind of taking the the values and the goals and the aspirations of capitalism and the might of of what you're talking about the leverage that we need. And that's this whole switch, your super. Change your super movement, and I just want to explain it a little further, because it feels like there's maybe a gap in understanding. And maybe before I launch into this and make sure I'm not kind of talking in the wrong direction. Who has changed their super

704
01:29:49.750 --> 01:29:51.250
Winton: to an ethical funds.

705
01:29:51.800 --> 01:29:57.109
Winton: So just a cockat, we're talking 7, 8, 9 of us. Something like that. Yeah, so

706
01:29:57.120 --> 01:30:09.040
Winton: so perfect and changing the back. Exactly. So there's a thing that occurs in Australia, where we're talking about like we don't have the leverage. And those capitalists should invest in these things. The reality is in Australia that

707
01:30:09.390 --> 01:30:25.889
Winton: more than 50% of the Asx 200 shares are held within pension funds. So they're effectively held by the public. And now this is not the same everywhere, but in Australia we have the capacity to be able to move our super around. We have like a huge leverage, and so.

708
01:30:26.150 --> 01:30:30.940
Winton: where. effectively like investing in

709
01:30:31.020 --> 01:30:48.749
Winton: currently, we're investing in things that are fossil fuels that are weapons based, that are, you know, things that gambling, etc. And we've all got that on our hands, but it doesn't need to be that way, like the biggest leverage, and the most evidence-based leverage is to switch our super. And in a group this size, without a doubt, we've got at least

710
01:30:48.750 --> 01:31:14.579
Winton: 10 million, probably up to 30 million dollars worth of investments right here. And you imagine that over extrapolated over an audience the number of people that marched in 2,019 at the climate marches was around 130,000, and I'm not sure if it's true now, because there was obviously a big swing of wealth over this kind of Covid phase. But at that time, if 130,000 people divested or reinvested their super into an ethical fund.

711
01:31:14.580 --> 01:31:22.939
Winton: effectively robbing the coal mines of capital to open up the new mines, and it would have immediately overnight.

712
01:31:23.370 --> 01:31:28.509
Winton: Yeah, funded the green transition that was required like that quickly.

713
01:31:28.540 --> 01:31:43.310
Winton: which is wild and wild, that we didn't do it in some ways, and wild that the opportunity is still there and wild that we're still talking about. What can we do when there's such a clean, obvious solution in this. And it it doesn't.

714
01:31:43.380 --> 01:31:48.240
Winton: It doesn't break the system. but it brings the the bomb

715
01:31:48.270 --> 01:32:11.349
Winton: people to, but because they're suddenly like, Oh, we need to quickly dismantle and rebuild the new industry around what has been shown here. So I just want to kind of put that out there that there's really obvious solutions, and some of them around reducing consumption of certain products, and especially meat. And one of them is, you know, changing our super. And I just want to kind of put that out there for like still haven't done that yet.

716
01:32:11.360 --> 01:32:12.470
Winton: Stop there.

717
01:32:12.570 --> 01:32:18.559
Winton: Yeah, II couldn't agree more. I mean, I think that. But but what what that means is

718
01:32:18.620 --> 01:32:21.739
Winton: the prophet motive is being

719
01:32:21.840 --> 01:32:23.840
Winton: dethroned, and

720
01:32:24.050 --> 01:32:25.730
and the

721
01:32:26.010 --> 01:32:31.890
Winton: you know, the investment funds are actually being directed in a political way, in other words.

722
01:32:31.940 --> 01:32:38.359
Winton: in a in a way that is ethically driven. And so you you

723
01:32:38.520 --> 01:32:43.319
Winton: yeah, it's exactly what needs to happen is the socialization of the capital market.

724
01:32:43.870 --> 01:32:58.219
Winton:  you in the room will try and get around. Okay. I'd like to bring some  light on the point that

725
01:32:58.390 --> 01:33:02.030
Winton: Steven on the question of Stephen and and

726
01:33:02.210 --> 01:33:03.480
Winton: and the answer.

727
01:33:03.660 --> 01:33:07.929
Winton: the transition, the transition is taking a long time. N.

728
01:33:07.980 --> 01:33:21.410
Winton: Don't make any mistake. It will take a long time. And it's not because the capital is lazy. it's because simply the technology is not there.

729
01:33:22.640 --> 01:33:24.500
Winton: We should realize that

730
01:33:24.930 --> 01:33:27.700
Winton: that there is no technology

731
01:33:27.970 --> 01:33:34.390
Winton: to transform the carbon industry into a non-carbon industry.

732
01:33:34.910 --> 01:33:38.710
Winton: The technology is not ready. People are working on it.

733
01:33:39.220 --> 01:33:42.990
Winton: Solar Panelau. getting more efficient.

734
01:33:43.100 --> 01:33:50.589
Winton: are getting cheaper, but don't believe that is because you put 10 m² of solar panel on your roof.

735
01:33:50.850 --> 01:33:52.010
Winton: It works.

736
01:33:52.230 --> 01:33:57.419
Winton: The government. Take your energy, pay for it, and you have a battery.

737
01:33:58.420 --> 01:34:02.340
Winton: It doesn't work like that at the mass scale.

738
01:34:03.190 --> 01:34:08.300
Winton: and the technology is not there. Hydrogen is not there. Carbon capture is not there?

739
01:34:08.540 --> 01:34:12.560
Winton: Evie is not there. I mean, you know how much

740
01:34:12.910 --> 01:34:18.100
Winton: a battery for an electrical car take to the nature?

741
01:34:18.360 --> 01:34:24.860
Winton: No, the technology is simply not there, and we will need time to

742
01:34:25.120 --> 01:34:27.640
Winton: come up. wheeze

743
01:34:27.860 --> 01:34:36.260
Winton: one technology and 2 technology which makes sense in terms of economical terms.

744
01:34:36.820 --> 01:34:40.079
Winton: And that is not the capital which is lazy.

745
01:34:40.370 --> 01:34:45.200
Winton: It's it's it's simply not possible to switch overnight

746
01:34:45.240 --> 01:34:47.989
Winton: from a carbon to a non-carbon ministry

747
01:34:49.030 --> 01:34:52.169
Winton: which sector it is

748
01:34:52.200 --> 01:34:53.390
Winton: transport

749
01:34:55.280 --> 01:34:57.170
Winton: energy generation

750
01:34:57.320 --> 01:35:00.529
Winton: chemical process. Steel making.

751
01:35:01.050 --> 01:35:05.900
Winton: There is simply not a technology which makes sense for time being.

752
01:35:08.530 --> 01:35:13.670
Winton: I guess. My only comment to that was, we're not.

753
01:35:14.230 --> 01:35:20.280
Winton:  I don't think many of us seized technology as the answer.

754
01:35:20.550 --> 01:35:27.420
Winton: I think it's a question of radically reworking patterns of production

755
01:35:27.440 --> 01:35:35.519
Winton: and and and distribution. I mean, for instance, one thing that would need to happen, I think, would be

756
01:35:35.860 --> 01:35:44.989
Winton: a sharp rise rise in taxation. So we could put a lot more resources into labor, intensive

757
01:35:45.350 --> 01:35:48.209
Winton: activities like medicine.

758
01:35:48.480 --> 01:36:08.940
Winton: education, social work, things that really people need really, things that have been absolutely de funded and allowed and and shrunken and allowed to fall away. So it's a it's a question of of re.

759
01:36:09.430 --> 01:36:21.429
Winton: of rearranging production as it is, and we probably wouldn't be making nearly as many cars and the rest of it. But we would be reemploying people

760
01:36:21.530 --> 01:36:23.469
Winton: in labor intensive

761
01:36:23.780 --> 01:36:30.220
Winton: active public sector activities, that really matter and that are really needed.

762
01:36:31.210 --> 01:36:35.749
Winton:  we'll go one more in the room and then back to Aila.

763
01:36:37.200 --> 01:36:43.000
Winton: I've changed what I was. Gonna say 3 times. Okay,

764
01:36:43.470 --> 01:36:47.859
Winton: one is. I'm not sure if people have heard of Saul Griffiths. But

765
01:36:47.880 --> 01:36:55.550
Winton: just to put it very simply, you know, he's his idea of electrifying everything.

766
01:36:55.610 --> 01:36:58.990
Winton: making sure electricity is from renewable.

767
01:36:59.140 --> 01:37:02.130
Winton: And and

768
01:37:03.640 --> 01:37:22.909
Winton: that's the way in, and it's a little bit dismissive of carbon. But that's just one way to do it very, very quickly. Get everybody onto electricity and to get all electricity. That's one thing. I want to go back to the fact that we really don't have much time. And

769
01:37:23.010 --> 01:37:39.500
Winton: you know, I really want to vote you for Prime Minister, Winton, you know. Seriously, we need more people thinking that way. But you know we have a democracy, as you know, as much as we all roll our eyes.

770
01:37:39.530 --> 01:37:46.590
Winton: If we want change to happen really quickly, it has to be big change and quick change.

771
01:37:47.140 --> 01:37:48.640
Winton: Now.

772
01:37:48.650 --> 01:37:55.989
Winton: you know, during wartime. We can see that governments are capable of changing quickly if they have to.

773
01:37:56.550 --> 01:37:58.300
Winton: And

774
01:37:58.510 --> 01:38:03.179
Winton: One way of doing this for people who are saying, Well, what do I do

775
01:38:03.400 --> 01:38:19.179
Winton: is to get everybody really to work on their Mps and senators again. It sounds a little bit trite, but if everyone did that they want the votes and the till movement has upset them.

776
01:38:19.470 --> 01:38:32.409
Winton:  This is just an idea for the answer to what can I do? And the answer is to not be an individual to to get together with your mates and work on your Mps.

777
01:38:33.030 --> 01:38:59.439
Winton: And that will bring huge changes. I think it's already brought the trigger mechanism in last Thursday night at 100'clock the trigger mechanism got pushed through. I like to think it's because so many of us, and you know, I've got 2 groups of people who visit Mps really hammered the Alp about the the water trigger, and now it's a way of Tanya stopping, fracking.

778
01:38:59.820 --> 01:39:08.950
Winton: and the Alp didn't do that willingly. It was really pushed from ordinary people like you going to your Mps.

779
01:39:08.980 --> 01:39:09.990
Winton: you know.

780
01:39:10.440 --> 01:39:30.449
Winton: Write, call, visit, just visit. Just roll up and tell them what you want. They have to record it. They have a little system of recording that even if your letter is, you know my name is such and such. I'm a retired, such and such. I want you to represent me, and they have to write it down.

781
01:39:31.010 --> 01:39:38.990
Winton: They get 200. They want. You vote if they get 200 of those people saying we want the water trigger, or we want the Eppc act to be changed.

782
01:39:39.010 --> 01:39:51.309
Winton: you know, and I've seen this in Adelaide. You know we've got very lethargic Alps actually joining with a band of other not so lethargic Alp to get the water trigger through.

783
01:39:51.360 --> 01:40:00.209
Winton: So if you want to know what to do, get together with your mates and write, visit or Ring

784
01:40:00.280 --> 01:40:08.019
Winton: Mps, it's very powerful. If thousands of people do it, we can stop

785
01:40:08.160 --> 01:40:13.610
Winton: coal oil and gas, I think, and not sounds idealistic.

786
01:40:13.630 --> 01:40:16.290
Winton: But I think it's possible, yeah.

787
01:40:16.370 --> 01:40:28.549
Winton: And so, just to answer Vivian's thing. I was a group of 10 Sasr people who went to Atlas Run Center for Independent studies last Thursday.

788
01:40:29.420 --> 01:40:49.290
Winton: It's an Atlas funded organisation, and we Spray canned their foyer. We couldn't get up in the lift, because, of course, you can't get up to the first floor. We Spray canned their foyer. We spray canned all the glass in front of their. We threw paint bombs on their windows, and we had. My husband was dressed up as their boss

789
01:40:49.310 --> 01:41:07.179
Winton: can't remember his name now, but we did that, and they took notice. They've been tweeting really terrible things about Xr. We've bothered them, and I really still recommend going on the streets and doing that it will shift the Overton window.

790
01:41:07.430 --> 01:41:13.869
Winton: So, you know. Think of creative things like that, and just do it. Talking about courage. Sorry.

791
01:41:13.990 --> 01:41:15.500
Winton: 3 things too many.

792
01:41:16.740 --> 01:41:18.990
Winton: Ayla online is next.

793
01:41:20.380 --> 01:41:28.429
Ayla Curtis: Thank you. And thanks for that contribution. Very. yeah. Couldn't agree more about writing to your Mp, but yeah, still.

794
01:41:28.440 --> 01:41:49.549
Ayla Curtis: taking those direct actions, my contribution now is really quick, and it kind of goes back to steven's point about jujitsu and how to move to maybe a post capitalist future. There's a wonderful author called Kim Stanley Robinson, who typically writes Sci-fi, but his books are all sort of based on how we can, how we can move

795
01:41:49.560 --> 01:42:01.600
Ayla Curtis: to post capitalist future in quite practical and I think, realistic way. So if there's anyone interested in. In. I don't know sci-fi books, maybe less so in some of the more.

796
01:42:02.020 --> 01:42:17.170
Ayla Curtis: probably I'm lowering the tone a little bit, bringing a sci-fi author into this conversation. But I've just found him to be incredibly insightful and yeah, quite practical in the suggestions he offers around, how he could move to a post capitalist future, looking at all sorts of different tools and mechanisms like

797
01:42:17.310 --> 01:42:23.070
Ayla Curtis: finance capital. So how we can use that against itself to move to

798
01:42:23.530 --> 01:42:25.030
climate.

799
01:42:25.100 --> 01:42:30.430
Ayla Curtis: climate, friendly future and social movements, different political structures, different.

800
01:42:30.470 --> 01:42:47.469
Ayla Curtis: business structures like Co. Ops. He's booked the ministry for the future kind of ties it all nicely together, and actually provides a bit of a pathway from now until you know some imagined future that we're all talking about. In a really engaging. And and yeah, I think quite practical way.

801
01:42:49.280 --> 01:42:51.899
Ayla Curtis: Team Stanley Robinson, if anybody's interested.

802
01:42:55.990 --> 01:43:01.150
Winton: Thank you, Eila, thank you for that. We've got Reena online next.

803
01:43:01.960 --> 01:43:11.350
rena czaplinska-archer: Oh, I just have A small quote which I have been using for the last 30 years in conversations like this.

804
01:43:11.420 --> 01:43:13.720
rena czaplinska-archer: And it was

805
01:43:15.760 --> 01:43:18.230
rena czaplinska-archer: actually came from a story.

806
01:43:18.290 --> 01:43:24.690
rena czaplinska-archer: Gavin Gavin is very good at this, but The story about fighting the dragon

807
01:43:24.810 --> 01:43:38.290
rena czaplinska-archer: wait for the dragon to shrink and sort of not fighting the whole system all at once. The quote I was going to quote was from Margaret Mead. Never doubt that a small

808
01:43:38.360 --> 01:43:44.809
rena czaplinska-archer: number of committed citizens can change. The world, indeed, is the only thing that ever did.

809
01:43:44.930 --> 01:43:57.690
rena czaplinska-archer: And I wanted to quote some examples of such things happening in Post First World War, Germany?  Well, as I'm a republic.

810
01:43:57.810 --> 01:43:59.550
rena czaplinska-archer: a created Bauhaus.

811
01:43:59.960 --> 01:44:09.639
rena czaplinska-archer: which came from a commitment of one convinced individual. That's Gropius, a whose

812
01:44:09.660 --> 01:44:18.859
rena czaplinska-archer: inspiring, inspiring figure, inviting number of great artists to come and join his Weimar Bauhaus school.

813
01:44:19.310 --> 01:44:22.539
rena czaplinska-archer:  That didn't come from Government

814
01:44:22.570 --> 01:44:25.080
rena czaplinska-archer: initiatives. That was individual group.

815
01:44:25.510 --> 01:44:35.399
rena czaplinska-archer: They did have, and they still have impact. And the other thing I wanted to mention I have in I didn't join

816
01:44:36.150 --> 01:44:44.889
rena czaplinska-archer: I tried to join, do something about my super, but instead, what I did on a smaller scale. I changed my electricity supplier from

817
01:44:45.210 --> 01:44:55.519
rena czaplinska-archer: whatever I was in Australia, or something into something which was cop from Byron Bay. It went past last year in June. was very disappointing.

818
01:44:56.670 --> 01:45:03.490
rena czaplinska-archer: I don't know if anybody else has had that experience, but I wanted to do that. I'm not saying that

819
01:45:03.520 --> 01:45:14.669
rena czaplinska-archer: as an example of what do or not to do. But I really like the example of thinking about what we can do ourselves within our our

820
01:45:15.170 --> 01:45:20.180
rena czaplinska-archer: footprint where we live and within our scale, and if

821
01:45:20.220 --> 01:45:25.120
rena czaplinska-archer: their only way is to join a large organization and then become a secretary or

822
01:45:25.160 --> 01:45:36.679
rena czaplinska-archer: box person, or something, and talk or write, or something. That's one way I myself, I of I was. II actually started with

823
01:45:37.380 --> 01:45:40.990
rena czaplinska-archer: during covet speaking up about various

824
01:45:41.000 --> 01:45:50.860
rena czaplinska-archer: decisions of the government about various things they were doing in here, and recognize suddenly that I'm surrounded by and within a system that has no

825
01:45:51.270 --> 01:46:11.200
rena czaplinska-archer: no resources in urban planning and and urban planning, thinking, and allows anybody with lots of money developer to decide about the shape of the streets and the shape of overshadowing and the shape of what happens with public transport as a result of it that's overcrowded or nothing is happening.

826
01:46:11.200 --> 01:46:22.469
rena czaplinska-archer: And so I started speaking about this to my neighbors and writing letters. Before I knew it, I got invited to be advisor on this thing, to the gum, to them,

827
01:46:22.780 --> 01:46:29.859
rena czaplinska-archer: To the council. So I am an unpaid advisor, and I don't know that I'm making any difference, but but I'm inside it.

828
01:46:29.920 --> 01:46:31.850
rena czaplinska-archer: and I can see how

829
01:46:31.870 --> 01:46:45.000
rena czaplinska-archer: I can see how slow the system is working, and how somebody like me, who is very impatient, and I like to put my energy into something that works.

830
01:46:46.930 --> 01:47:03.019
rena czaplinska-archer: I'm just just talking about what we can do ourselves. And I'm I'm doing that. I'm I'm I'm really interested in in joining in with other people and creating something. But what I have done is I have initiated this

831
01:47:03.060 --> 01:47:16.530
rena czaplinska-archer: painting group and drawing group and going to the desert. II recognize that I myself as an immigrant. I don't know enough about geography of this country, and I don't know enough about history of this country, and I know don't know enough about

832
01:47:16.530 --> 01:47:37.070
rena czaplinska-archer: very much about anything about this country, except for I live in Melbourne and Brisbane, and maybe I've been to Lauro, and I have done some bush walking in Kimberly. But I mean and I put myself on a learning curve by actually going travelling and painting and drawing and looking at places. And you know,

833
01:47:37.640 --> 01:47:42.829
rena czaplinska-archer: I think we're talking about taking agency, you know, being

834
01:47:43.130 --> 01:47:55.470
rena czaplinska-archer: not leaving it to others to decide about my health or about my knowledge, and and I have to rely on somebody. I go and learn myself. I go and walk it. I go and talk it. I want. I'll go and see it.

835
01:47:55.650 --> 01:47:58.469
rena czaplinska-archer: I go and look at it, and

836
01:47:58.880 --> 01:48:01.620
rena czaplinska-archer:  well.

837
01:48:01.740 --> 01:48:02.979
rena czaplinska-archer: it changes me.

838
01:48:04.460 --> 01:48:10.850
rena czaplinska-archer: That's where I am. It's just small steps. But now. thank you.

839
01:48:11.710 --> 01:48:15.120
rena czaplinska-archer: Thank you. This was a comment. It wasn't really a question

840
01:48:15.240 --> 01:48:16.620
Winton: out of time.

841
01:48:16.870 --> 01:48:19.759
Winton: So maybe

842
01:48:20.560 --> 01:48:25.529
Winton: I know people have got lots of ideas that we're still going

843
01:48:25.600 --> 01:48:32.909
Winton: on those ideas, and we will then, no doubt come up again that we have other opportunities. so perhaps we'll leave it there and

844
01:48:33.320 --> 01:48:37.000
Winton: come back in 53 min to see.

845
01:48:39.700 --> 01:48:40.420
rena czaplinska-archer: Thank you.